Engagement 2 has to be run again, illegal substitution with Si Yong, 10 yard penalty.
Send the SAME (not like we can't see the tactics you already used, but maybe some other conditions will come into play this time around) tactics you had to Belial plus whatever you want to do with the extra guy you took out, he will rerun it. It won't change much, Ann ran the battle with Zhang Han at 66 supply at the start when he had 56, but it is a question of principle and you might not get so lucky this time
As a reference:
Melee Layer
Commander: Ba Rong [Marshal] (+3000 Max Troops, +15% Recruitment) 89-91-44-65-20 Aid I, Charge II, Instructor II, Qiangshu I, Raid II, Rupture II, Scout I Items: Horse (Spd +2), Black Ogre's Ancient Dragon Head (Mgt +3, Cha +2), Iron Cuirass (Mgt +3), Billhook (Mgt +2), Book of Formations (Com +3)
Subcommander: Guan Ying [Marshall] (+3000 Max Troops, +15% Recruitment) 87-85-70-70-65 Charge II, Dash II, Entrench II, Military_Admin I, Raid I, Sortie III, Yueshu I
Subcommander: Fan Kuai [General] (+2000 Max Troops, +10% Recruitment) 79-94-52-62-63 Assemble II, Challenge III, Discipline I, Entrench II, Inspire II, Instructor I, Military_Admin I, Raid II, Rupture II, Yueshu II, Items: Horse (Spd +2), Halbred (Mgt +2)
Subcommander: Mei Ji [General] (+2000 Max Troops, +10% Recruitment) 86-69-33-72-41 Aid III, Dash II, Discipline II, Military_Admin I, Wall II Items: Wei Liaozi (+2 Command, +2 Judgment, *Aid), Xiongnu Mare (+6 Spd)
Subcommander: Yun Ling 62-94*-21-66-68 Yueshu III, gongshu II, raid II, politian II, Challange I Items: Steel Chainmail (+7 armour), Sapphire (+1 speed, +3 defence, Horse) Ravager (+3 Axe)
Subcommander: (EX!) Jin Qiu 76-80-61-76-57 Deride I, Entrench II, Scout II, Yueshu I
Troops: 30630 (97)
Armaments: 26847 Pi Spears, 4166 Halberds, 22984 Leather Armors, 3534 Horses
Support Layer:
Commander: Han Xin [Supreme Commander] (+4000 Max Troops, +20% Recruitment) 99-52-95-76-58 Confuse II, Cover I, Dash II, Decoy III, Entrench II, Military_Admin II, Pierce III, Rupture I, Sortie I, Spy I, Wall III
Subcommander: Di Wan [General] (+2000 Max Troops, +10% Recruitment) 80-34-80-85-45 Artisan II, Cover II, Decoy II, Entrench II, Gongshu I, Volley II Items: Oracle Spear (+2 Might, +1 Judge), Di Tribe Amulet (+4 Charm), Horse (Speed +1)
Subcommander: Bei Xin [District Manager] (+5000 Max Troops, +25% Civil Development, +25% Recruitment) 81-49-92-52-51 Aid II, Confuse II, Decoy I, Jeer II, Military_Admin I, Sortie I, Wall I Items: Book of Maneuvers (Com+2), Book of History (Int+2), Leather Cuirass (Mgt+1)
Subcommander: Miaogu Pan [District Justiciar] (+10% Civil Development) 42-41-76-60-80 Dash II, Pierce I, Rally II, Rupture I
Troops: 24703 (87)
Armaments: 24703 Bows, 14180 Leather Armors
4613 captives
Supply at 90
VS
Melee Layer:
Melee Commander: Zhang Han;95-96-73-78-71/Assemble III, Challenge I, Dash I, Discipline III, Entrench I, Envelop III, Escort II, Inspire II, Instructor II, Jianshu II, Qiangshu I, Rally I, Scout II, Sortie II, Wall III Horse +3 Speed, +4 Sword
Subcommander: Hua Jin;58-76-59-46-77/Challenge I, Cover II, Discipline I, Jianshu I, Raid II
Subcommander: Jie Jing;77-60-62-68-36/Civil_Admin II, Cover I, Faze II
Subcommander: Juang Bu;70-63-57-62-69/Discipline I, Diplomat I, Inspire I, Pierce I, Politician I, Rupture I, Sortie I
Subcommander: Quan Liao;61-66-59-42-63/Entrench II, Envelop I, Instructor I, Qiangshu II
Subcommander: Da Shuang;54-52-45-64-67/Assemble I, Charge I, Decoy I, Diplomat I, Entrench I, Spy I
Subcommander: Zhang Ping;75-67-58-60-64/Envelop II, Instructor I, Intimidate I, Military_Admin I, Qiangshu I, Trainer I
Soldiers: 15557 (63)
Armaments: 0 Leather, 0 Bronze, 5366 Pi Spears, 0 Halberds, 0 Javelins, 0 Horses, 0 Chariots
Support Layer:
Support Commander: CAPTURED Ping Zhuo;71-59-68-73-45/Confuse II, Maraud I, Raid I, Scribe I
Subcommander: CAPTURED Sui Bing;54-40-71-71-54/Delay II, Envelop I, Instructor I, Poison II, Trainer I, Volley I
Subcommander: CAPTURED Dan Zu;56-70-67-69-48/Cover II, Entangle I, Rupture II
Soldiers: 0 (23)
Armaments: 0 Leather, 0 Pi Spears, 0 Javelins, 0 Bows, 0 Crossbows, 0 Horses, 0 Siege Engines
2804 captives
Current Spoils: 9227 Pi Spears, 1022 Halberds, 0 Javelins, 5641 Leather Armor, 0 Bronze Armor, 0 Bows, 0 Crossbows, 868 Horses, 0 Chariots, and 0 Seige Engines.
Supply at 56