Blighter!

Zeren · Post by **Zeren** » Sun Nov 02, 2008 10:18 pm

Maybe, but I generally don't go for advisor types and I prefer Jia Xu to Xun Yu

What happened to Guo Jia? >.>

+1 Jia Xu
-2 Xun Yu

Cao Cao 33
Cao Ren 28
Jia Xu 28
Li Dian 12
Sima Yi 27
Xiahou Yuan 26
Xun Yu 32
Zhang He 24
Zhang Liao 24

Zhao Ren · Post by **Zhao Ren** » Sun Nov 02, 2008 10:28 pm

Thing is though... Xun Yu was so much more than an advisor. He recruited a lot of Cao Cao's advisors to him, which is more than Jia Xu can say. Oh, sure, Jia Xu was always right, but he didn't do much once he joined Wei. Sorta faded into history. At least Xun Yu had a lasting effect in the people he recruited. That said though, Jia Xu is still a worthy choice for winning this blighter. Hell, most of these people are >.>

+1 Xun Yu
-2 Li Dian

Cao Cao 33
Cao Ren 28
Jia Xu 28
Li Dian 10
Sima Yi 27
Xiahou Yuan 26
Xun Yu 33
Zhang He 24
Zhang Liao 24

Zeren · Post by **Zeren** » Sun Nov 02, 2008 11:03 pm

Hmm, I'm convinced!

+1 Xiahou Yuan
-2 Jia Xu

Cao Cao 33
Cao Ren 28
Jia Xu 26
Li Dian 10
Sima Yi 27
Xiahou Yuan 27
Xun Yu 33
Zhang He 24
Zhang Liao 24

Shinpusan · Post by **Shinpusan** » Mon Nov 03, 2008 12:50 am

Zhang He shouldn't be around still. He was good, but Xu Huang totally trumps him. Hell, Xu Huang trumps the overrated Zhang Liao as well.

+1 Xun Yu
-2 Zhang He

Cao Cao 33
Cao Ren 28
Jia Xu 26
Li Dian 10
Sima Yi 27
Xiahou Yuan 27
Xun Yu 33
Zhang He 24
Zhang Liao 24

Big Grizzy · Post by **Big Grizzy** » Mon Nov 03, 2008 1:05 am

Cao Cao has entirely too many points and Li Dian was a good guy.

+1 Li Dian
-2 Cao Cao

Cao Cao 31
Cao Ren 28
Jia Xu 26
Li Dian 11
Sima Yi 27
Xiahou Yuan 27
Xun Yu 33
Zhang He 24
Zhang Liao 24

Shinpusan · Post by **Shinpusan** » Mon Nov 03, 2008 1:08 am

Agreed! He was a great guy. Oh and, Zhang He should have been at 22, and Xun Yu at 34, my mistake. So the correct numbers would now be:

+1 Li Dian
-2 Zhang He

Cao Cao 31
Cao Ren 28
Jia Xu 26
Li Dian 12
Sima Yi 27
Xiahou Yuan 27
Xun Yu 33
Zhang He 20
Zhang Liao 24

Zhao Ren · Post by **Zhao Ren** » Mon Nov 03, 2008 7:51 am

Li Dian may have been a great guy, but he has almost no deeds to his name, unlike everyone else on here <.<

+1 Cao Cao
-2 Li Dian

Cao Cao 32
Cao Ren 28
Jia Xu 26
Li Dian 10
Sima Yi 27
Xiahou Yuan 27
Xun Yu 34
Zhang He 20
Zhang Liao 24

Indestructable · Post by **Indestructable** » Mon Nov 03, 2008 8:00 am

+1 Cao Cao
-2 Li Dian

Cao Cao 33
Cao Ren 28
Jia Xu 26
Li Dian 8
Sima Yi 27
Xiahou Yuan 27
Xun Yu 34
Zhang He 20
Zhang Liao 24

Zhao Ren · Post by **Zhao Ren** » Mon Nov 03, 2008 8:16 am

Oh, and please. Zhang Liao and Zhang He > Xu Huang any day. Xu Huang didn't do much, save aid in the defeat of Guan Yu, which Pang De was doing fine and well at before Yu Jin had to screw it up. Zhang Liao at least managed to screw up Sun Quan's major campaign, and Zhang He made it so Liu Bei and co. didn't barge through Han Zhong after Xiahou Yuan's death. Oh, and he ruined a few of Zhuge's Northern campaigns.

+1 Xun Yu
-2 Li Dian

Cao Cao 33
Cao Ren 28
Jia Xu 26
Li Dian 6
Sima Yi 27
Xiahou Yuan 27
Xun Yu 35
Zhang He 20
Zhang Liao 24

Duke Williams · Post by **Duke Williams** » Mon Nov 03, 2008 8:45 am

Obviously Zhang Liao deserves to win. No other is a greater General than he.

+1 Zhang Liao
-2 Li Dian

Cao Cao 33
Cao Ren 28
Jia Xu 26
Li Dian 4
Sima Yi 27
Xiahou Yuan 27
Xun Yu 35
Zhang He 20
Zhang Liao 25