Tactic balance

User avatar
Phailak
Administrator
Administrator
Posts: 6198
Joined: Fri Aug 18, 2006 9:55 am
Location: PHP world of Warlords :)
Contact:

Re: Tactic balance

Postby Phailak » Thu May 11, 2017 1:41 pm

OK so with reducing supply hits and recups to 5-10-15 and keeping at 50% min

Attacker's challenge is refused, loss of 10 morale for defenders!


Battle results Part 1

Army Melee Soldiers Support Soldiers Supplies Morale Melee Attack Melee Armaments Support Attack Support Armaments Melee Defense Support Defense Speed
Attackers 4890 2851 100 54 187 4890 173 1618 178 177 146
Defenders 4500 1500 100 36 195 4500 220 1500 170 204 127

Ma Dieu's efficiency is at 100
Chao Niu's efficiency is at 100
Mang Yue's efficiency is at 100
Wu Haiyao's efficiency is at 100
You Meng's efficiency is at 100
Zhuang Wu's efficiency is at 100
Fang Han's efficiency is at 100
Pan Shaozu's efficiency is at 100
Huang Liao's efficiency is at 100
Anguo Shuangdi's efficiency is at 100
Jia Huangfu's efficiency is at 100
Mei Shun's efficiency is at 100
Re Ben's efficiency is at 100
Xian Dun's efficiency is at 100
Shen Feng's efficiency is at 100
Fei Lai's efficiency is at 100
Ce Canhuang's efficiency is at 100
Jie Juetie's efficiency is at 100
Kuan Dun's efficiency is at 100
Cao Ren's efficiency is at 100
Lu Qian's efficiency is at 100
Xu Huang's efficiency is at 100
Xu Shang's efficiency is at 100
Yin Shu's efficiency is at 100
Zhu Gai's efficiency is at 100
Sima Yi's efficiency is at 100
Xiahou Dun's efficiency is at 100
Zhang He's efficiency is at 100
Mao MaRen's efficiency is at 100
Ban Dong's efficiency is at 100
Cang Ben's efficiency is at 100
Chao Jian's efficiency is at 100
Gao Lue's efficiency is at 100
Jiu Xue's efficiency is at 100
Luo Ou's efficiency is at 100
Yin Gong's efficiency is at 100

Huang Liao fails to use Deride 2 (had 47% chance to succeed, got 61)
Ce Canhuang succeeds to use Deride 1 (had 76% chance to succeed, got 65) to lower opp support morale by 10
Cao Ren succeeds to use Discipline 3 (had 77% chance to succeed, got 23) to raise own soldiers morale by 30
Mao MaRen succeeds to use Discipline 2 (had 90% chance to succeed, got 3) to raise own soldiers morale by 20
Ma Dieu succeeds to use Raid 3 (had 90% chance to succeed, got 78) to lower opp support supplies by 15
Fang Han succeeds to use Escort 1 (had 55% chance to succeed, got 54) to raise own army supplies by 5
Re Ben succeeds to use Raid 2 (had 90% chance to succeed, got 68) to lower opp support supplies by 10
Fei Lai succeeds to use Escort 2 (had 62% chance to succeed, got 42) to raise own army supplies by 10
Jie Juetie fails to use Raid 1 (had 87% chance to succeed, got 91)
Pan Shaozu succeeds to use Poison 2 (had 41% chance to succeed, got 20) to lower opp support supplies by 10
Shen Feng fails to use Guard 2 (had 46% chance to succeed, got 54)
Xiahou Dun succeeds to use Raid 2 (had 90% chance to succeed, got 39) to lower opp support supplies by 10
Jiu Xue succeeds to use Raid 1 (had 90% chance to succeed, got 84) to lower opp support supplies by 5
Sima Yi succeeds to use Poison 2 (had 90% chance to succeed, got 60) to lower opp support supplies by 10
Cang Ben fails to use Poison 1 (had 12% chance to succeed, got 61)
Luo Ou fails to use Guard 1 (had 57% chance to succeed, got 59)
Xu Huang succeeds to use Charge 3 (had 87% chance to succeed, got 30) to raise own melee attack by 30 (195)
Zhang He succeeds to use Rupture 2 (had 90% chance to succeed, got 86) to lower opp melee defense by 20 (158)
Kuan Dun succeeds to use Faze 1 (had 89% chance to succeed, got 37) to lower opp officer (Mao MaRen) effectivness by 10
Ban Dong fails to use Aid 1 (had 10% chance to succeed, got 27)

Updated stats after tactics
Army Melee Soldiers Support Soldiers Supplies Morale Melee Attack Melee Armaments Support Attack Support Armaments Melee Defense Support Defense Speed
Attackers 4890 2851 90 54 179 4890 165 1618 158 177 146
Defenders 4500 1500 65 76 195 4500 186 1500 170 204 127



Att Mel vs Def Mel 0.0737058823529
Att Sup vs Def Mel 0.0931764705882
Att Sup vs Def Sup 0.0776470588235
Def Mel vs Att Mel 0.0863924050633
Def Sup vs Att Mel 0.113012658228
Def Sup vs Att Sup 0.100881355932
Att Mel Att 179
Def Mel Def 170
Def Mel Att 195
Att Mel Def 158
Att Sup Att 165
Def Sup Def 204
Def Sup Att 186
Att Sup Def 177
Attacker's speed is higher and will strike first!

[1] is 0.0931764705882
From Support layer, Attacker has dealt Defender 259 casualties to their Melee layer, 259 armaments were lost, Defender now has 4241 soldiers left in Melee layer, 5741 total.

[1] is 0.0737058823529
From Melee layer, Attacker has dealt Defender 666 casualties to their Melee layer, 666 armaments were lost, Defender now has 3575 soldiers left in Melee layer, 5075 total.

[1] is 0.113012658228
From Support layer, Defender has dealt Attacker 167 casualties to their Melee layer, 167 armaments were lost, Attacker now has 4723 soldiers left in Melee layer, 7574 total.

[1] is 0.0863924050633
From Melee layer, Defender has dealt Attacker 739 casualties to their Melee layer, 739 armaments were lost, Attacker now has 3984 soldiers left in Melee layer, 6835 total.
Ma Dieu's recuperates 15 efficiency
Chao Niu's recuperates 13 efficiency
Mang Yue's recuperates 15 efficiency
Wu Haiyao's recuperates 12 efficiency
You Meng's recuperates 12 efficiency
Zhuang Wu's recuperates 12 efficiency
Fang Han's recuperates 19 efficiency
Pan Shaozu's recuperates 19 efficiency
Huang Liao's recuperates 21 efficiency
Anguo Shuangdi's recuperates 14 efficiency
Jia Huangfu's recuperates 14 efficiency
Mei Shun's recuperates 12 efficiency
Re Ben's recuperates 18 efficiency
Xian Dun's recuperates 12 efficiency
Shen Feng's recuperates 18 efficiency
Fei Lai's recuperates 17 efficiency
Ce Canhuang's recuperates 16 efficiency
Jie Juetie's recuperates 17 efficiency
Kuan Dun's recuperates 22 efficiency
Cao Ren's recuperates 21 efficiency
Lu Qian's recuperates 21 efficiency
Xu Huang's recuperates 21 efficiency
Xu Shang's recuperates 20 efficiency
Yin Shu's recuperates 17 efficiency
Zhu Gai's recuperates 19 efficiency
Sima Yi's recuperates 26 efficiency
Xiahou Dun's recuperates 24 efficiency
Zhang He's recuperates 24 efficiency
Mao MaRen's recuperates 22 efficiency
Ban Dong's recuperates 20 efficiency
Cang Ben's recuperates 14 efficiency
Chao Jian's recuperates 18 efficiency
Gao Lue's recuperates 17 efficiency
Jiu Xue's recuperates 19 efficiency
Luo Ou's recuperates 20 efficiency
Yin Gong's recuperates 19 efficiency

Ma Dieu's efficiency is at 70
Chao Niu's efficiency is at 100
Mang Yue's efficiency is at 100
Wu Haiyao's efficiency is at 100
You Meng's efficiency is at 100
Zhuang Wu's efficiency is at 100
Fang Han's efficiency is at 100
Pan Shaozu's efficiency is at 89
Huang Liao's efficiency is at 91
Anguo Shuangdi's efficiency is at 100
Jia Huangfu's efficiency is at 100
Mei Shun's efficiency is at 100
Re Ben's efficiency is at 88
Xian Dun's efficiency is at 100
Shen Feng's efficiency is at 88
Fei Lai's efficiency is at 87
Ce Canhuang's efficiency is at 100
Jie Juetie's efficiency is at 100
Kuan Dun's efficiency is at 100
Cao Ren's efficiency is at 76
Lu Qian's efficiency is at 100
Xu Huang's efficiency is at 76
Xu Shang's efficiency is at 100
Yin Shu's efficiency is at 100
Zhu Gai's efficiency is at 100
Sima Yi's efficiency is at 96
Xiahou Dun's efficiency is at 94
Zhang He's efficiency is at 94
Mao MaRen's efficiency is at 82
Ban Dong's efficiency is at 100
Cang Ben's efficiency is at 99
Chao Jian's efficiency is at 100
Gao Lue's efficiency is at 100
Jiu Xue's efficiency is at 100
Luo Ou's efficiency is at 100
Yin Gong's efficiency is at 100

Battle results Part 2

Army Melee Soldiers Support Soldiers Supplies Morale Melee Attack Melee Armaments Support Attack Support Armaments Melee Defense Support Defense Speed
Attackers 3984 2851 90 54 179 3984 165 1618 178 177 132
Defenders 3575 1500 65 76 165 3575 186 1500 170 204 111

Ma Dieu's efficiency is at 70
Chao Niu's efficiency is at 100
Mang Yue's efficiency is at 100
Wu Haiyao's efficiency is at 100
You Meng's efficiency is at 100
Zhuang Wu's efficiency is at 100
Fang Han's efficiency is at 100
Pan Shaozu's efficiency is at 89
Huang Liao's efficiency is at 91
Anguo Shuangdi's efficiency is at 100
Jia Huangfu's efficiency is at 100
Mei Shun's efficiency is at 100
Re Ben's efficiency is at 88
Xian Dun's efficiency is at 100
Shen Feng's efficiency is at 88
Fei Lai's efficiency is at 87
Ce Canhuang's efficiency is at 100
Jie Juetie's efficiency is at 100
Kuan Dun's efficiency is at 100
Cao Ren's efficiency is at 76
Lu Qian's efficiency is at 100
Xu Huang's efficiency is at 76
Xu Shang's efficiency is at 100
Yin Shu's efficiency is at 100
Zhu Gai's efficiency is at 100
Sima Yi's efficiency is at 96
Xiahou Dun's efficiency is at 94
Zhang He's efficiency is at 94
Mao MaRen's efficiency is at 82
Ban Dong's efficiency is at 100
Cang Ben's efficiency is at 99
Chao Jian's efficiency is at 100
Gao Lue's efficiency is at 100
Jiu Xue's efficiency is at 100
Luo Ou's efficiency is at 100
Yin Gong's efficiency is at 100

Huang Liao succeeds to use Deride 1 (had 43% chance to succeed, got 15) to lower opp support morale by 9
Mao MaRen fails to use Discipline 2 (had 75% chance to succeed, got 91)
Fang Han succeeds to use Escort 1 (had 55% chance to succeed, got 11) to raise own army supplies by 5
Re Ben succeeds to use Raid 1 (had 79% chance to succeed, got 70) to lower opp support supplies by 4
Fei Lai succeeds to use Escort 2 (had 54% chance to succeed, got 2) to raise own army supplies by 9
Jie Juetie succeeds to use Raid 2 (had 87% chance to succeed, got 25) to lower opp support supplies by 10
Shen Feng fails to use Guard 2 (had 40% chance to succeed, got 78)
Xiahou Dun succeeds to use Raid 2 (had 90% chance to succeed, got 63) to lower opp support supplies by 9
Jiu Xue succeeds to use Raid 1 (had 90% chance to succeed, got 90) to lower opp support supplies by 5
Sima Yi fails to use Poison 2 (had 90% chance to succeed, got 100)
Ban Dong fails to use Guard 1 (had 10% chance to succeed, got 65)
Cang Ben fails to use Poison 1 (had 12% chance to succeed, got 68)
Zhang He succeeds to use Rupture 2 (had 90% chance to succeed, got 54) to lower opp melee defense by 19 (159)
Luo Ou succeeds to use Barricade 1 (had 90% chance to succeed, got 33) to raise own support defense by 10 (214)
Kuan Dun succeeds to use Faze 1 (had 89% chance to succeed, got 9) to lower opp officer (Mao MaRen) effectivness by 10
Pan Shaozu succeeds to use Succor 1 (had 69% chance to succeed, got 45) to raise own officer (Shen Feng) effectivness by 9
Ce Canhuang fails to use Aid 2 (had 17% chance to succeed, got 53)
Cao Ren fails to use Aid 2 (had 44% chance to succeed, got 63)
Xu Huang fails to use Aid 1 (had 34% chance to succeed, got 83)

Updated stats after tactics
Army Melee Soldiers Support Soldiers Supplies Morale Melee Attack Melee Armaments Support Attack Support Armaments Melee Defense Support Defense Speed
Attackers 3984 2851 90 54 179 3984 165 1618 159 177 132
Defenders 3575 1500 51 67 153 3575 172 1500 170 214 111



Att Mel vs Def Mel 0.0737058823529
Att Sup vs Def Mel 0.0931764705882
Att Sup vs Def Sup 0.0740186915888
Def Mel vs Att Mel 0.067358490566
Def Sup vs Att Mel 0.103849056604
Def Sup vs Att Sup 0.0932881355932
Att Mel Att 179
Def Mel Def 170
Def Mel Att 153
Att Mel Def 159
Att Sup Att 165
Def Sup Def 214
Def Sup Att 172
Att Sup Def 177
Attacker's speed is higher and will strike first!

[1] is 0.0931764705882
From Support layer, Attacker has dealt Defender 262 casualties to their Melee layer, 262 armaments were lost, Defender now has 3313 soldiers left in Melee layer, 4813 total.

[1] is 0.0737058823529
From Melee layer, Attacker has dealt Defender 523 casualties to their Melee layer, 523 armaments were lost, Defender now has 2790 soldiers left in Melee layer, 4290 total.

[1] is 0.103849056604
From Support layer, Defender has dealt Attacker 154 casualties to their Melee layer, 154 armaments were lost, Attacker now has 3830 soldiers left in Melee layer, 6681 total.

[1] is 0.067358490566
From Melee layer, Defender has dealt Attacker 460 casualties to their Melee layer, 460 armaments were lost, Attacker now has 3370 soldiers left in Melee layer, 6221 total.
Ma Dieu's recuperates 15 efficiency
Chao Niu's recuperates 13 efficiency
Mang Yue's recuperates 15 efficiency
Wu Haiyao's recuperates 12 efficiency
You Meng's recuperates 12 efficiency
Zhuang Wu's recuperates 12 efficiency
Fang Han's recuperates 19 efficiency
Pan Shaozu's recuperates 19 efficiency
Huang Liao's recuperates 21 efficiency
Anguo Shuangdi's recuperates 14 efficiency
Jia Huangfu's recuperates 14 efficiency
Mei Shun's recuperates 12 efficiency
Re Ben's recuperates 18 efficiency
Xian Dun's recuperates 12 efficiency
Shen Feng's recuperates 18 efficiency
Fei Lai's recuperates 17 efficiency
Ce Canhuang's recuperates 16 efficiency
Jie Juetie's recuperates 17 efficiency
Kuan Dun's recuperates 22 efficiency
Cao Ren's recuperates 20 efficiency
Lu Qian's recuperates 20 efficiency
Xu Huang's recuperates 20 efficiency
Xu Shang's recuperates 19 efficiency
Yin Shu's recuperates 16 efficiency
Zhu Gai's recuperates 18 efficiency
Sima Yi's recuperates 25 efficiency
Xiahou Dun's recuperates 23 efficiency
Zhang He's recuperates 23 efficiency
Mao MaRen's recuperates 21 efficiency
Ban Dong's recuperates 19 efficiency
Cang Ben's recuperates 13 efficiency
Chao Jian's recuperates 17 efficiency
Gao Lue's recuperates 16 efficiency
Jiu Xue's recuperates 18 efficiency
Luo Ou's recuperates 19 efficiency
Yin Gong's recuperates 18 efficiency

Ma Dieu's efficiency is at 85
Chao Niu's efficiency is at 100
Mang Yue's efficiency is at 100
Wu Haiyao's efficiency is at 100
You Meng's efficiency is at 100
Zhuang Wu's efficiency is at 100
Fang Han's efficiency is at 100
Pan Shaozu's efficiency is at 93
Huang Liao's efficiency is at 97
Anguo Shuangdi's efficiency is at 100
Jia Huangfu's efficiency is at 100
Mei Shun's efficiency is at 100
Re Ben's efficiency is at 91
Xian Dun's efficiency is at 100
Shen Feng's efficiency is at 85
Fei Lai's efficiency is at 74
Ce Canhuang's efficiency is at 86
Jie Juetie's efficiency is at 87
Kuan Dun's efficiency is at 100
Cao Ren's efficiency is at 66
Lu Qian's efficiency is at 100
Xu Huang's efficiency is at 81
Xu Shang's efficiency is at 100
Yin Shu's efficiency is at 100
Zhu Gai's efficiency is at 100
Sima Yi's efficiency is at 91
Xiahou Dun's efficiency is at 87
Zhang He's efficiency is at 87
Mao MaRen's efficiency is at 63
Ban Dong's efficiency is at 100
Cang Ben's efficiency is at 97
Chao Jian's efficiency is at 100
Gao Lue's efficiency is at 100
Jiu Xue's efficiency is at 100
Luo Ou's efficiency is at 100
Yin Gong's efficiency is at 100

Battle results Part 3

Army Melee Soldiers Support Soldiers Supplies Morale Melee Attack Melee Armaments Support Attack Support Armaments Melee Defense Support Defense Speed
Attackers 3370 2851 90 54 179 3370 165 1618 178 177 133
Defenders 2790 1500 51 67 153 2790 172 1500 170 204 83

Ma Dieu's efficiency is at 85
Chao Niu's efficiency is at 100
Mang Yue's efficiency is at 100
Wu Haiyao's efficiency is at 100
You Meng's efficiency is at 100
Zhuang Wu's efficiency is at 100
Fang Han's efficiency is at 100
Pan Shaozu's efficiency is at 93
Huang Liao's efficiency is at 97
Anguo Shuangdi's efficiency is at 100
Jia Huangfu's efficiency is at 100
Mei Shun's efficiency is at 100
Re Ben's efficiency is at 91
Xian Dun's efficiency is at 100
Shen Feng's efficiency is at 85
Fei Lai's efficiency is at 74
Ce Canhuang's efficiency is at 86
Jie Juetie's efficiency is at 87
Kuan Dun's efficiency is at 100
Cao Ren's efficiency is at 66
Lu Qian's efficiency is at 100
Xu Huang's efficiency is at 81
Xu Shang's efficiency is at 100
Yin Shu's efficiency is at 100
Zhu Gai's efficiency is at 100
Sima Yi's efficiency is at 91
Xiahou Dun's efficiency is at 87
Zhang He's efficiency is at 87
Mao MaRen's efficiency is at 63
Ban Dong's efficiency is at 100
Cang Ben's efficiency is at 97
Chao Jian's efficiency is at 100
Gao Lue's efficiency is at 100
Jiu Xue's efficiency is at 100
Luo Ou's efficiency is at 100
Yin Gong's efficiency is at 100

Ce Canhuang succeeds to use Deride 1 (had 65% chance to succeed, got 52) to lower opp support morale by 9
Mao MaRen succeeds to use Discipline 2 (had 58% chance to succeed, got 29) to raise own soldiers morale by 13
Ma Dieu succeeds to use Raid 3 (had 77% chance to succeed, got 31) to lower opp support supplies by 13
Fang Han fails to use Escort 1 (had 55% chance to succeed, got 78)
Re Ben succeeds to use Raid 2 (had 82% chance to succeed, got 53) to lower opp support supplies by 9
Fei Lai fails to use Escort 2 (had 46% chance to succeed, got 74)
Jie Juetie succeeds to use Raid 1 (had 76% chance to succeed, got 14) to lower opp support supplies by 4
Shen Feng fails to use Guard 2 (had 39% chance to succeed, got 47)
Xiahou Dun succeeds to use Raid 2 (had 90% chance to succeed, got 88) to lower opp support supplies by 9
Jiu Xue succeeds to use Raid 1 (had 90% chance to succeed, got 5) to lower opp support supplies by 5
Sima Yi succeeds to use Poison 2 (had 90% chance to succeed, got 57) to lower opp support supplies by 9
Cang Ben fails to use Poison 1 (had 12% chance to succeed, got 57)
Luo Ou succeeds to use Guard 1 (had 57% chance to succeed, got 7) to raise own army supplies by 5
Xu Huang fails to use Charge 3 (had 70% chance to succeed, got 82)
Zhang He succeeds to use Rupture 2 (had 90% chance to succeed, got 34) to lower opp melee defense by 17 (161)
Kuan Dun succeeds to use Faze 1 (had 89% chance to succeed, got 69) to lower opp officer (Mao MaRen) effectivness by 10
Pan Shaozu succeeds to use Succor 2 (had 72% chance to succeed, got 71) to raise own officer (Shen Feng) effectivness by 19
Huang Liao fails to use Aid 1 (had 33% chance to succeed, got 34)
Cao Ren succeeds to use Aid 2 (had 53% chance to succeed, got 34) to raise own officer (Sima Yi) effectivness by 13
Ban Dong fails to use Aid 1 (had 19% chance to succeed, got 38)

Updated stats after tactics
Army Melee Soldiers Support Soldiers Supplies Morale Melee Attack Melee Armaments Support Attack Support Armaments Melee Defense Support Defense Speed
Attackers 3370 2851 67 54 160 3370 147 1618 161 177 133
Defenders 2790 1500 30 71 136 2790 152 1500 170 204 83



Att Mel vs Def Mel 0.0658823529412
Att Sup vs Def Mel 0.0830117647059
Att Sup vs Def Sup 0.0691764705882
Def Mel vs Att Mel 0.0591304347826
Def Sup vs Att Mel 0.0906335403727
Def Sup vs Att Sup 0.0824406779661
Att Mel Att 160
Def Mel Def 170
Def Mel Att 136
Att Mel Def 161
Att Sup Att 147
Def Sup Def 204
Def Sup Att 152
Att Sup Def 177
Attacker's speed is higher and will strike first!

[1] is 0.0830117647059
From Support layer, Attacker has dealt Defender 243 casualties to their Melee layer, 243 armaments were lost, Defender now has 2547 soldiers left in Melee layer, 4047 total.

[1] is 0.0658823529412
From Melee layer, Attacker has dealt Defender 393 casualties to their Melee layer, 393 armaments were lost, Defender now has 2154 soldiers left in Melee layer, 3654 total.

[1] is 0.0906335403727
From Support layer, Defender has dealt Attacker 135 casualties to their Melee layer, 135 armaments were lost, Attacker now has 3235 soldiers left in Melee layer, 6086 total.

[1] is 0.0591304347826
From Melee layer, Defender has dealt Attacker 313 casualties to their Melee layer, 313 armaments were lost, Attacker now has 2922 soldiers left in Melee layer, 5773 total.
Ma Dieu's recuperates 15 efficiency
Chao Niu's recuperates 13 efficiency
Mang Yue's recuperates 15 efficiency
Wu Haiyao's recuperates 12 efficiency
You Meng's recuperates 12 efficiency
Zhuang Wu's recuperates 12 efficiency
Fang Han's recuperates 19 efficiency
Pan Shaozu's recuperates 19 efficiency
Huang Liao's recuperates 21 efficiency
Anguo Shuangdi's recuperates 14 efficiency
Jia Huangfu's recuperates 14 efficiency
Mei Shun's recuperates 12 efficiency
Re Ben's recuperates 18 efficiency
Xian Dun's recuperates 12 efficiency
Shen Feng's recuperates 18 efficiency
Fei Lai's recuperates 17 efficiency
Ce Canhuang's recuperates 16 efficiency
Jie Juetie's recuperates 17 efficiency
Kuan Dun's recuperates 22 efficiency
Cao Ren's recuperates 20 efficiency
Lu Qian's recuperates 20 efficiency
Xu Huang's recuperates 20 efficiency
Xu Shang's recuperates 19 efficiency
Yin Shu's recuperates 16 efficiency
Zhu Gai's recuperates 18 efficiency
Sima Yi's recuperates 25 efficiency
Xiahou Dun's recuperates 23 efficiency
Zhang He's recuperates 23 efficiency
Mao MaRen's recuperates 21 efficiency
Ban Dong's recuperates 19 efficiency
Cang Ben's recuperates 13 efficiency
Chao Jian's recuperates 17 efficiency
Gao Lue's recuperates 16 efficiency
Jiu Xue's recuperates 18 efficiency
Luo Ou's recuperates 19 efficiency
Yin Gong's recuperates 18 efficiency

Ma Dieu's efficiency is at 55
Chao Niu's efficiency is at 100
Mang Yue's efficiency is at 100
Wu Haiyao's efficiency is at 100
You Meng's efficiency is at 100
Zhuang Wu's efficiency is at 100
Fang Han's efficiency is at 100
Pan Shaozu's efficiency is at 82
Huang Liao's efficiency is at 100
Anguo Shuangdi's efficiency is at 100
Jia Huangfu's efficiency is at 100
Mei Shun's efficiency is at 100
Re Ben's efficiency is at 79
Xian Dun's efficiency is at 100
Shen Feng's efficiency is at 92
Fei Lai's efficiency is at 61
Ce Canhuang's efficiency is at 87
Jie Juetie's efficiency is at 89
Kuan Dun's efficiency is at 100
Cao Ren's efficiency is at 56
Lu Qian's efficiency is at 100
Xu Huang's efficiency is at 56
Xu Shang's efficiency is at 100
Yin Shu's efficiency is at 100
Zhu Gai's efficiency is at 100
Sima Yi's efficiency is at 99
Xiahou Dun's efficiency is at 80
Zhang He's efficiency is at 80
Mao MaRen's efficiency is at 44
Ban Dong's efficiency is at 100
Cang Ben's efficiency is at 95
Chao Jian's efficiency is at 100
Gao Lue's efficiency is at 100
Jiu Xue's efficiency is at 100
Luo Ou's efficiency is at 100
Yin Gong's efficiency is at 100

Battle results Part 4

Army Melee Soldiers Support Soldiers Supplies Morale Melee Attack Melee Armaments Support Attack Support Armaments Melee Defense Support Defense Speed
Attackers 2922 2851 67 54 160 2922 147 1618 178 177 99
Defenders 2154 1500 30 71 136 2154 152 1500 170 204 50

Ma Dieu's efficiency is at 55
Chao Niu's efficiency is at 100
Mang Yue's efficiency is at 100
Wu Haiyao's efficiency is at 100
You Meng's efficiency is at 100
Zhuang Wu's efficiency is at 100
Fang Han's efficiency is at 100
Pan Shaozu's efficiency is at 82
Huang Liao's efficiency is at 100
Anguo Shuangdi's efficiency is at 100
Jia Huangfu's efficiency is at 100
Mei Shun's efficiency is at 100
Re Ben's efficiency is at 79
Xian Dun's efficiency is at 100
Shen Feng's efficiency is at 92
Fei Lai's efficiency is at 61
Ce Canhuang's efficiency is at 87
Jie Juetie's efficiency is at 89
Kuan Dun's efficiency is at 100
Cao Ren's efficiency is at 56
Lu Qian's efficiency is at 100
Xu Huang's efficiency is at 56
Xu Shang's efficiency is at 100
Yin Shu's efficiency is at 100
Zhu Gai's efficiency is at 100
Sima Yi's efficiency is at 99
Xiahou Dun's efficiency is at 80
Zhang He's efficiency is at 80
Mao MaRen's efficiency is at 44
Ban Dong's efficiency is at 100
Cang Ben's efficiency is at 95
Chao Jian's efficiency is at 100
Gao Lue's efficiency is at 100
Jiu Xue's efficiency is at 100
Luo Ou's efficiency is at 100
Yin Gong's efficiency is at 100

Mao MaRen succeeds to use Discipline 2 (had 40% chance to succeed, got 19) to raise own soldiers morale by 9
Fang Han succeeds to use Escort 1 (had 55% chance to succeed, got 9) to raise own army supplies by 5
Re Ben succeeds to use Raid 1 (had 71% chance to succeed, got 14) to lower opp support supplies by 4
Fei Lai fails to use Escort 2 (had 38% chance to succeed, got 54)
Jie Juetie succeeds to use Raid 2 (had 77% chance to succeed, got 30) to lower opp support supplies by 9
Shen Feng fails to use Guard 2 (had 42% chance to succeed, got 57)
Xiahou Dun succeeds to use Raid 2 (had 90% chance to succeed, got 48) to lower opp support supplies by 8
Jiu Xue succeeds to use Raid 1 (had 90% chance to succeed, got 81) to lower opp support supplies by 5
Sima Yi succeeds to use Poison 2 (had 90% chance to succeed, got 86) to lower opp support supplies by 10
Ban Dong fails to use Guard 1 (had 10% chance to succeed, got 78)
Cang Ben fails to use Poison 1 (had 11% chance to succeed, got 59)
Zhang He succeeds to use Rupture 2 (had 86% chance to succeed, got 38) to lower opp melee defense by 16 (162)
Luo Ou succeeds to use Barricade 1 (had 90% chance to succeed, got 51) to raise own support defense by 10 (214)
Kuan Dun succeeds to use Faze 1 (had 89% chance to succeed, got 73) to lower opp officer (Mao MaRen) effectivness by 10
Pan Shaozu fails to use Succor 1 (had 63% chance to succeed, got 84)
Huang Liao fails to use Aid 1 (had 34% chance to succeed, got 38)
Ce Canhuang fails to use Aid 2 (had 15% chance to succeed, got 77)
Cao Ren fails to use Aid 2 (had 32% chance to succeed, got 41)
Xu Huang fails to use Aid 1 (had 25% chance to succeed, got 95)

Updated stats after tactics
Army Melee Soldiers Support Soldiers Supplies Morale Melee Attack Melee Armaments Support Attack Support Armaments Melee Defense Support Defense Speed
Attackers 2922 2851 49 54 146 2922 132 1618 162 177 99
Defenders 2154 1500 17 80 124 2154 139 1500 170 214 50



Att Mel vs Def Mel 0.0601176470588
Att Sup vs Def Mel 0.0745411764706
Att Sup vs Def Sup 0.059214953271
Def Mel vs Att Mel 0.0535802469136
Def Sup vs Att Mel 0.0823703703704
Def Sup vs Att Sup 0.0753898305085
Att Mel Att 146
Def Mel Def 170
Def Mel Att 124
Att Mel Def 162
Att Sup Att 132
Def Sup Def 214
Def Sup Att 139
Att Sup Def 177
Attacker's speed is higher and will strike first!

[1] is 0.0745411764706
From Support layer, Attacker has dealt Defender 218 casualties to their Melee layer, 218 armaments were lost, Defender now has 1936 soldiers left in Melee layer, 3436 total.

[1] is 0.0601176470588
From Melee layer, Attacker has dealt Defender 284 casualties to their Melee layer, 284 armaments were lost, Defender now has 1652 soldiers left in Melee layer, 3152 total.

[1] is 0.0823703703704
From Support layer, Defender has dealt Attacker 121 casualties to their Melee layer, 121 armaments were lost, Attacker now has 2801 soldiers left in Melee layer, 5652 total.

[1] is 0.0535802469136
From Melee layer, Defender has dealt Attacker 238 casualties to their Melee layer, 238 armaments were lost, Attacker now has 2563 soldiers left in Melee layer, 5414 total.
Ma Dieu's recuperates 15 efficiency
Chao Niu's recuperates 13 efficiency
Mang Yue's recuperates 15 efficiency
Wu Haiyao's recuperates 12 efficiency
You Meng's recuperates 12 efficiency
Zhuang Wu's recuperates 12 efficiency
Fang Han's recuperates 19 efficiency
Pan Shaozu's recuperates 19 efficiency
Huang Liao's recuperates 21 efficiency
Anguo Shuangdi's recuperates 14 efficiency
Jia Huangfu's recuperates 14 efficiency
Mei Shun's recuperates 12 efficiency
Re Ben's recuperates 18 efficiency
Xian Dun's recuperates 12 efficiency
Shen Feng's recuperates 18 efficiency
Fei Lai's recuperates 17 efficiency
Ce Canhuang's recuperates 16 efficiency
Jie Juetie's recuperates 17 efficiency
Kuan Dun's recuperates 22 efficiency
Cao Ren's recuperates 21 efficiency
Lu Qian's recuperates 21 efficiency
Xu Huang's recuperates 21 efficiency
Xu Shang's recuperates 20 efficiency
Yin Shu's recuperates 17 efficiency
Zhu Gai's recuperates 19 efficiency
Sima Yi's recuperates 26 efficiency
Xiahou Dun's recuperates 24 efficiency
Zhang He's recuperates 24 efficiency
Mao MaRen's recuperates 22 efficiency
Ban Dong's recuperates 20 efficiency
Cang Ben's recuperates 14 efficiency
Chao Jian's recuperates 18 efficiency
Gao Lue's recuperates 17 efficiency
Jiu Xue's recuperates 19 efficiency
Luo Ou's recuperates 20 efficiency
Yin Gong's recuperates 19 efficiency

Ma Dieu's efficiency is at 70
Chao Niu's efficiency is at 100
Mang Yue's efficiency is at 100
Wu Haiyao's efficiency is at 100
You Meng's efficiency is at 100
Zhuang Wu's efficiency is at 100
Fang Han's efficiency is at 100
Pan Shaozu's efficiency is at 86
Huang Liao's efficiency is at 100
Anguo Shuangdi's efficiency is at 100
Jia Huangfu's efficiency is at 100
Mei Shun's efficiency is at 100
Re Ben's efficiency is at 82
Xian Dun's efficiency is at 100
Shen Feng's efficiency is at 80
Fei Lai's efficiency is at 48
Ce Canhuang's efficiency is at 73
Jie Juetie's efficiency is at 76
Kuan Dun's efficiency is at 100
Cao Ren's efficiency is at 47
Lu Qian's efficiency is at 100
Xu Huang's efficiency is at 62
Xu Shang's efficiency is at 100
Yin Shu's efficiency is at 100
Zhu Gai's efficiency is at 100
Sima Yi's efficiency is at 95
Xiahou Dun's efficiency is at 74
Zhang He's efficiency is at 74
Mao MaRen's efficiency is at 26
Ban Dong's efficiency is at 100
Cang Ben's efficiency is at 94
Chao Jian's efficiency is at 100
Gao Lue's efficiency is at 100
Jiu Xue's efficiency is at 100
Luo Ou's efficiency is at 100
Yin Gong's efficiency is at 100

Battle results Part 5

Army Melee Soldiers Support Soldiers Supplies Morale Melee Attack Melee Armaments Support Attack Support Armaments Melee Defense Support Defense Speed
Attackers 2563 2851 49 54 146 2563 132 1618 178 177 73
Defenders 1652 1500 17 80 124 1652 139 1500 170 204 30

Ma Dieu's efficiency is at 70
Chao Niu's efficiency is at 100
Mang Yue's efficiency is at 100
Wu Haiyao's efficiency is at 100
You Meng's efficiency is at 100
Zhuang Wu's efficiency is at 100
Fang Han's efficiency is at 100
Pan Shaozu's efficiency is at 86
Huang Liao's efficiency is at 100
Anguo Shuangdi's efficiency is at 100
Jia Huangfu's efficiency is at 100
Mei Shun's efficiency is at 100
Re Ben's efficiency is at 82
Xian Dun's efficiency is at 100
Shen Feng's efficiency is at 80
Fei Lai's efficiency is at 48
Ce Canhuang's efficiency is at 73
Jie Juetie's efficiency is at 76
Kuan Dun's efficiency is at 100
Cao Ren's efficiency is at 47
Lu Qian's efficiency is at 100
Xu Huang's efficiency is at 62
Xu Shang's efficiency is at 100
Yin Shu's efficiency is at 100
Zhu Gai's efficiency is at 100
Sima Yi's efficiency is at 95
Xiahou Dun's efficiency is at 74
Zhang He's efficiency is at 74
Mao MaRen's efficiency is at 26
Ban Dong's efficiency is at 100
Cang Ben's efficiency is at 94
Chao Jian's efficiency is at 100
Gao Lue's efficiency is at 100
Jiu Xue's efficiency is at 100
Luo Ou's efficiency is at 100
Yin Gong's efficiency is at 100

Ce Canhuang fails to use Deride 1 (had 55% chance to succeed, got 92)
Mao MaRen fails to use Discipline 2 (had 24% chance to succeed, got 62)
Ma Dieu fails to use Raid 3 (had 64% chance to succeed, got 85)
Fang Han succeeds to use Escort 1 (had 55% chance to succeed, got 30) to raise own army supplies by 5
Re Ben succeeds to use Raid 2 (had 74% chance to succeed, got 49) to lower opp support supplies by 8
Fei Lai fails to use Escort 2 (had 30% chance to succeed, got 51)
Jie Juetie fails to use Raid 1 (had 66% chance to succeed, got 76)
Shen Feng fails to use Guard 2 (had 37% chance to succeed, got 80)
Xiahou Dun succeeds to use Raid 2 (had 84% chance to succeed, got 69) to lower opp support supplies by 7
Jiu Xue succeeds to use Raid 1 (had 90% chance to succeed, got 84) to lower opp support supplies by 5
Sima Yi fails to use Poison 2 (had 90% chance to succeed, got 93)
Cang Ben fails to use Poison 1 (had 11% chance to succeed, got 23)
Luo Ou succeeds to use Guard 1 (had 57% chance to succeed, got 14) to raise own army supplies by 5
Xu Huang succeeds to use Charge 3 (had 54% chance to succeed, got 50) to raise own melee attack by 19 (141)
Zhang He succeeds to use Rupture 2 (had 80% chance to succeed, got 70) to lower opp melee defense by 15 (163)
Kuan Dun fails to use Faze 1 (had 89% chance to succeed, got 94)
Pan Shaozu succeeds to use Succor 2 (had 66% chance to succeed, got 36) to raise own officer (Shen Feng) effectivness by 17
Huang Liao fails to use Aid 1 (had 34% chance to succeed, got 48)
Cao Ren fails to use Aid 2 (had 26% chance to succeed, got 53)
Ban Dong fails to use Aid 1 (had 10% chance to succeed, got 73)

Updated stats after tactics
Army Melee Soldiers Support Soldiers Supplies Morale Melee Attack Melee Armaments Support Attack Support Armaments Melee Defense Support Defense Speed
Attackers 2563 2851 42 54 140 2563 127 1618 163 177 73
Defenders 1652 1500 14 80 141 1652 136 1500 170 204 30



Att Mel vs Def Mel 0.0576470588235
Att Sup vs Def Mel 0.0717176470588
Att Sup vs Def Sup 0.0597647058824
Def Mel vs Att Mel 0.0605521472393
Def Sup vs Att Mel 0.0800981595092
Def Sup vs Att Sup 0.0737627118644
Att Mel Att 140
Def Mel Def 170
Def Mel Att 141
Att Mel Def 163
Att Sup Att 127
Def Sup Def 204
Def Sup Att 136
Att Sup Def 177
Attacker's speed is higher and will strike first!

[1] is 0.0717176470588
From Support layer, Attacker has dealt Defender 211 casualties to their Melee layer, 211 armaments were lost, Defender now has 1441 soldiers left in Melee layer, 2941 total.

[1] is 0.0576470588235
From Melee layer, Attacker has dealt Defender 225 casualties to their Melee layer, 225 armaments were lost, Defender now has 1216 soldiers left in Melee layer, 2716 total.

[1] is 0.0800981595092
From Support layer, Defender has dealt Attacker 120 casualties to their Melee layer, 120 armaments were lost, Attacker now has 2443 soldiers left in Melee layer, 5294 total.

[1] is 0.0605521472393
From Melee layer, Defender has dealt Attacker 218 casualties to their Melee layer, 218 armaments were lost, Attacker now has 2225 soldiers left in Melee layer, 5076 total.
Ma Dieu's recuperates 15 efficiency
Chao Niu's recuperates 13 efficiency
Mang Yue's recuperates 15 efficiency
Wu Haiyao's recuperates 12 efficiency
You Meng's recuperates 12 efficiency
Zhuang Wu's recuperates 12 efficiency
Fang Han's recuperates 19 efficiency
Pan Shaozu's recuperates 19 efficiency
Huang Liao's recuperates 21 efficiency
Anguo Shuangdi's recuperates 14 efficiency
Jia Huangfu's recuperates 14 efficiency
Mei Shun's recuperates 12 efficiency
Re Ben's recuperates 18 efficiency
Xian Dun's recuperates 12 efficiency
Shen Feng's recuperates 18 efficiency
Fei Lai's recuperates 17 efficiency
Ce Canhuang's recuperates 16 efficiency
Jie Juetie's recuperates 17 efficiency
Kuan Dun's recuperates 22 efficiency
Cao Ren's recuperates 21 efficiency
Lu Qian's recuperates 21 efficiency
Xu Huang's recuperates 21 efficiency
Xu Shang's recuperates 20 efficiency
Yin Shu's recuperates 17 efficiency
Zhu Gai's recuperates 19 efficiency
Sima Yi's recuperates 26 efficiency
Xiahou Dun's recuperates 24 efficiency
Zhang He's recuperates 24 efficiency
Mao MaRen's recuperates 22 efficiency
Ban Dong's recuperates 20 efficiency
Cang Ben's recuperates 14 efficiency
Chao Jian's recuperates 18 efficiency
Gao Lue's recuperates 17 efficiency
Jiu Xue's recuperates 19 efficiency
Luo Ou's recuperates 20 efficiency
Yin Gong's recuperates 19 efficiency

Ma Dieu's efficiency is at 40
Chao Niu's efficiency is at 100
Mang Yue's efficiency is at 100
Wu Haiyao's efficiency is at 100
You Meng's efficiency is at 100
Zhuang Wu's efficiency is at 100
Fang Han's efficiency is at 100
Pan Shaozu's efficiency is at 75
Huang Liao's efficiency is at 100
Anguo Shuangdi's efficiency is at 100
Jia Huangfu's efficiency is at 100
Mei Shun's efficiency is at 100
Re Ben's efficiency is at 70
Xian Dun's efficiency is at 100
Shen Feng's efficiency is at 85
Fei Lai's efficiency is at 35
Ce Canhuang's efficiency is at 74
Jie Juetie's efficiency is at 78
Kuan Dun's efficiency is at 100
Cao Ren's efficiency is at 38
Lu Qian's efficiency is at 100
Xu Huang's efficiency is at 38
Xu Shang's efficiency is at 100
Yin Shu's efficiency is at 100
Zhu Gai's efficiency is at 100
Sima Yi's efficiency is at 91
Xiahou Dun's efficiency is at 68
Zhang He's efficiency is at 68
Mao MaRen's efficiency is at 22
Ban Dong's efficiency is at 100
Cang Ben's efficiency is at 93
Chao Jian's efficiency is at 100
Gao Lue's efficiency is at 100
Jiu Xue's efficiency is at 100
Luo Ou's efficiency is at 100
Yin Gong's efficiency is at 100

Battle results Part 6

Army Melee Soldiers Support Soldiers Supplies Morale Melee Attack Melee Armaments Support Attack Support Armaments Melee Defense Support Defense Speed
Attackers 2225 2851 42 54 140 2225 127 1618 178 177 63
Defenders 1216 1500 14 80 122 1216 136 1500 170 204 25

Ma Dieu's efficiency is at 40
Chao Niu's efficiency is at 100
Mang Yue's efficiency is at 100
Wu Haiyao's efficiency is at 100
You Meng's efficiency is at 100
Zhuang Wu's efficiency is at 100
Fang Han's efficiency is at 100
Pan Shaozu's efficiency is at 75
Huang Liao's efficiency is at 100
Anguo Shuangdi's efficiency is at 100
Jia Huangfu's efficiency is at 100
Mei Shun's efficiency is at 100
Re Ben's efficiency is at 70
Xian Dun's efficiency is at 100
Shen Feng's efficiency is at 85
Fei Lai's efficiency is at 35
Ce Canhuang's efficiency is at 74
Jie Juetie's efficiency is at 78
Kuan Dun's efficiency is at 100
Cao Ren's efficiency is at 38
Lu Qian's efficiency is at 100
Xu Huang's efficiency is at 38
Xu Shang's efficiency is at 100
Yin Shu's efficiency is at 100
Zhu Gai's efficiency is at 100
Sima Yi's efficiency is at 91
Xiahou Dun's efficiency is at 68
Zhang He's efficiency is at 68
Mao MaRen's efficiency is at 22
Ban Dong's efficiency is at 100
Cang Ben's efficiency is at 93
Chao Jian's efficiency is at 100
Gao Lue's efficiency is at 100
Jiu Xue's efficiency is at 100
Luo Ou's efficiency is at 100
Yin Gong's efficiency is at 100

Mao MaRen succeeds to use Discipline 2 (had 20% chance to succeed, got 2) to raise own soldiers morale by 4
Xiahou Dun fails to use Raid 2 (had 78% chance to succeed, got 97)
Jiu Xue succeeds to use Raid 1 (had 90% chance to succeed, got 31) to lower opp support supplies by 5
Sima Yi succeeds to use Poison 2 (had 90% chance to succeed, got 85) to lower opp support supplies by 9
Cang Ben fails to use Poison 1 (had 11% chance to succeed, got 18)
Luo Ou fails to use Guard 1 (had 57% chance to succeed, got 60)
Ma Dieu fails to use Charge 2 (had 32% chance to succeed, got 36)
Fang Han succeeds to use Decoy 1 (had 78% chance to succeed, got 10) to lower opp melee attack by 10 (112)
Re Ben succeeds to use Charge 1 (had 68% chance to succeed, got 21) to raise own melee attack by 7 (136)
Fei Lai succeeds to use Charge 3 (had 32% chance to succeed, got 21) to raise own melee attack by 11 (147)
Pan Shaozu succeeds to use Support 2 (had 59% chance to succeed, got 39) to raise own melee attack by 15 (162)
Shen Feng fails to use Volley 2 (had 30% chance to succeed, got 70)
Cao Ren fails to use Charge 1 (had 35% chance to succeed, got 71)
Xu Huang succeeds to use Charge 3 (had 33% chance to succeed, got 14) to raise own melee attack by 11 (123)
Jie Juetie succeeds to use Rupture 1 (had 66% chance to succeed, got 49) to lower opp melee defense by 8 (162)
Kuan Dun succeeds to use Wall 1 (had 70% chance to succeed, got 40) to raise own melee defense by 10 (188)
Huang Liao fails to use Scout 3 (had 66% chance to succeed, got 98)
Zhang He succeeds to use Rupture 2 (had 73% chance to succeed, got 42) to lower opp melee defense by 14 (174)
Ce Canhuang fails to use Aid 2 (had 13% chance to succeed, got 62)
Ban Dong fails to use Aid 1 (had 10% chance to succeed, got 12)

Updated stats after tactics
Army Melee Soldiers Support Soldiers Supplies Morale Melee Attack Melee Armaments Support Attack Support Armaments Melee Defense Support Defense Speed
Attackers 2225 2851 28 54 162 2225 116 1618 174 177 63
Defenders 1216 1500 14 84 123 1216 136 1500 162 204 25



Att Mel vs Def Mel 0.07
Att Sup vs Def Mel 0.0687407407407
Att Sup vs Def Sup 0.0545882352941
Def Mel vs Att Mel 0.0494827586207
Def Sup vs Att Mel 0.0750344827586
Def Sup vs Att Sup 0.0737627118644
Att Mel Att 162
Def Mel Def 162
Def Mel Att 123
Att Mel Def 174
Att Sup Att 116
Def Sup Def 204
Def Sup Att 136
Att Sup Def 177
Attacker's speed is higher and will strike first!

[1] is 0.0687407407407
From Support layer, Attacker has dealt Defender 202 casualties to their Melee layer, 202 armaments were lost, Defender now has 1014 soldiers left in Melee layer, 2514 total.

[1] is 0.07
From Melee layer, Attacker has dealt Defender 222 casualties to their Melee layer, 222 armaments were lost, Defender now has 792 soldiers left in Melee layer, 2292 total.

[1] is 0.0750344827586
From Support layer, Defender has dealt Attacker 108 casualties to their Melee layer, 108 armaments were lost, Attacker now has 2117 soldiers left in Melee layer, 4968 total.

[1] is 0.0494827586207
From Melee layer, Defender has dealt Attacker 141 casualties to their Melee layer, 141 armaments were lost, Attacker now has 1976 soldiers left in Melee layer, 4827 total.
Ma Dieu's recuperates 15 efficiency
Chao Niu's recuperates 13 efficiency
Mang Yue's recuperates 15 efficiency
Wu Haiyao's recuperates 12 efficiency
You Meng's recuperates 12 efficiency
Zhuang Wu's recuperates 12 efficiency
Fang Han's recuperates 19 efficiency
Pan Shaozu's recuperates 19 efficiency
Huang Liao's recuperates 21 efficiency
Anguo Shuangdi's recuperates 14 efficiency
Jia Huangfu's recuperates 14 efficiency
Mei Shun's recuperates 12 efficiency
Re Ben's recuperates 18 efficiency
Xian Dun's recuperates 12 efficiency
Shen Feng's recuperates 18 efficiency
Fei Lai's recuperates 17 efficiency
Ce Canhuang's recuperates 16 efficiency
Jie Juetie's recuperates 17 efficiency
Kuan Dun's recuperates 22 efficiency
Cao Ren's recuperates 22 efficiency
Lu Qian's recuperates 22 efficiency
Xu Huang's recuperates 22 efficiency
Xu Shang's recuperates 21 efficiency
Yin Shu's recuperates 18 efficiency
Zhu Gai's recuperates 20 efficiency
Sima Yi's recuperates 27 efficiency
Xiahou Dun's recuperates 25 efficiency
Zhang He's recuperates 25 efficiency
Mao MaRen's recuperates 23 efficiency
Ban Dong's recuperates 21 efficiency
Cang Ben's recuperates 15 efficiency
Chao Jian's recuperates 19 efficiency
Gao Lue's recuperates 18 efficiency
Jiu Xue's recuperates 20 efficiency
Luo Ou's recuperates 21 efficiency
Yin Gong's recuperates 20 efficiency

Ma Dieu's efficiency is at 25
Chao Niu's efficiency is at 100
Mang Yue's efficiency is at 100
Wu Haiyao's efficiency is at 100
You Meng's efficiency is at 100
Zhuang Wu's efficiency is at 100
Fang Han's efficiency is at 100
Pan Shaozu's efficiency is at 64
Huang Liao's efficiency is at 76
Anguo Shuangdi's efficiency is at 100
Jia Huangfu's efficiency is at 100
Mei Shun's efficiency is at 100
Re Ben's efficiency is at 73
Xian Dun's efficiency is at 100
Shen Feng's efficiency is at 73
Fei Lai's efficiency is at 17
Ce Canhuang's efficiency is at 60
Jie Juetie's efficiency is at 80
Kuan Dun's efficiency is at 100
Cao Ren's efficiency is at 45
Lu Qian's efficiency is at 100
Xu Huang's efficiency is at 22
Xu Shang's efficiency is at 100
Yin Shu's efficiency is at 100
Zhu Gai's efficiency is at 100
Sima Yi's efficiency is at 88
Xiahou Dun's efficiency is at 63
Zhang He's efficiency is at 63
Mao MaRen's efficiency is at 23
Ban Dong's efficiency is at 100
Cang Ben's efficiency is at 93
Chao Jian's efficiency is at 100
Gao Lue's efficiency is at 100
Jiu Xue's efficiency is at 100
Luo Ou's efficiency is at 100
Yin Gong's efficiency is at 100

User avatar
Phailak
Administrator
Administrator
Posts: 6198
Joined: Fri Aug 18, 2006 9:55 am
Location: PHP world of Warlords :)
Contact:

Re: Tactic balance

Postby Phailak » Thu May 11, 2017 2:33 pm

Finally with morale affecting defense like supplies affect attacks:

Attacker's challenge is refused, loss of 10 morale for defenders!


Battle results Part 1

Army Melee Soldiers Support Soldiers Supplies Morale Melee Attack Melee Armaments Support Attack Support Armaments Melee Defense Support Defense Speed
Attackers 4890 2851 100 54 187 4890 173 1618 140 177 146
Defenders 4500 1500 100 36 195 4500 220 1500 119 204 127

Ma Dieu's efficiency is at 100
Chao Niu's efficiency is at 100
Mang Yue's efficiency is at 100
Wu Haiyao's efficiency is at 100
You Meng's efficiency is at 100
Zhuang Wu's efficiency is at 100
Fang Han's efficiency is at 100
Pan Shaozu's efficiency is at 100
Huang Liao's efficiency is at 100
Anguo Shuangdi's efficiency is at 100
Jia Huangfu's efficiency is at 100
Mei Shun's efficiency is at 100
Re Ben's efficiency is at 100
Xian Dun's efficiency is at 100
Shen Feng's efficiency is at 100
Fei Lai's efficiency is at 100
Ce Canhuang's efficiency is at 100
Jie Juetie's efficiency is at 100
Kuan Dun's efficiency is at 100
Cao Ren's efficiency is at 100
Lu Qian's efficiency is at 100
Xu Huang's efficiency is at 100
Xu Shang's efficiency is at 100
Yin Shu's efficiency is at 100
Zhu Gai's efficiency is at 100
Sima Yi's efficiency is at 100
Xiahou Dun's efficiency is at 100
Zhang He's efficiency is at 100
Mao MaRen's efficiency is at 100
Ban Dong's efficiency is at 100
Cang Ben's efficiency is at 100
Chao Jian's efficiency is at 100
Gao Lue's efficiency is at 100
Jiu Xue's efficiency is at 100
Luo Ou's efficiency is at 100
Yin Gong's efficiency is at 100

Huang Liao succeeds to use Deride 2 (had 47% chance to succeed, got 16) to lower opp support morale by 20
Ce Canhuang succeeds to use Deride 1 (had 76% chance to succeed, got 71) to lower opp support morale by 10
Cao Ren succeeds to use Discipline 3 (had 77% chance to succeed, got 12) to raise own soldiers morale by 30
Mao MaRen succeeds to use Discipline 2 (had 90% chance to succeed, got 22) to raise own soldiers morale by 20
Ma Dieu succeeds to use Raid 3 (had 90% chance to succeed, got 49) to lower opp support supplies by 15
Fang Han fails to use Escort 1 (had 55% chance to succeed, got 58)
Re Ben succeeds to use Raid 2 (had 90% chance to succeed, got 60) to lower opp support supplies by 10
Fei Lai fails to use Escort 2 (had 62% chance to succeed, got 89)
Jie Juetie succeeds to use Raid 1 (had 87% chance to succeed, got 8) to lower opp support supplies by 5
Pan Shaozu succeeds to use Poison 2 (had 41% chance to succeed, got 31) to lower opp support supplies by 10
Shen Feng fails to use Guard 2 (had 46% chance to succeed, got 74)
Xiahou Dun succeeds to use Raid 2 (had 90% chance to succeed, got 57) to lower opp support supplies by 10
Jiu Xue succeeds to use Raid 1 (had 90% chance to succeed, got 60) to lower opp support supplies by 5
Sima Yi succeeds to use Poison 2 (had 90% chance to succeed, got 32) to lower opp support supplies by 10
Cang Ben fails to use Poison 1 (had 12% chance to succeed, got 83)
Luo Ou succeeds to use Guard 1 (had 57% chance to succeed, got 20) to raise own army supplies by 5
Xu Huang succeeds to use Charge 3 (had 87% chance to succeed, got 86) to raise own melee attack by 30 (195)
Zhang He succeeds to use Rupture 2 (had 90% chance to succeed, got 71) to lower opp melee defense by 20 (118)
Kuan Dun fails to use Faze 1 (had 89% chance to succeed, got 99)
Ban Dong fails to use Aid 1 (had 10% chance to succeed, got 85)

Updated stats after tactics
Army Melee Soldiers Support Soldiers Supplies Morale Melee Attack Melee Armaments Support Attack Support Armaments Melee Defense Support Defense Speed
Attackers 4890 2851 75 54 167 4890 153 1618 118 113 146
Defenders 4500 1500 65 56 195 4500 186 1500 135 126 127



Att Mel vs Def Mel 0.0865925925926
Att Sup vs Def Mel 0.1088
Att Sup vs Def Sup 0.116571428571
Def Mel vs Att Mel 0.115677966102
Def Sup vs Att Mel 0.151322033898
Def Sup vs Att Sup 0.158017699115
Att Mel Att 167
Def Mel Def 135
Def Mel Att 195
Att Mel Def 118
Att Sup Att 153
Def Sup Def 126
Def Sup Att 186
Att Sup Def 113
Attacker's speed is higher and will strike first!

[1] is 0.1088
From Support layer, Attacker has dealt Defender 311 casualties to their Melee layer, 311 armaments were lost, Defender now has 4189 soldiers left in Melee layer, 5689 total.

[1] is 0.0865925925926
From Melee layer, Attacker has dealt Defender 753 casualties to their Melee layer, 753 armaments were lost, Defender now has 3436 soldiers left in Melee layer, 4936 total.

[1] is 0.151322033898
From Support layer, Defender has dealt Attacker 235 casualties to their Melee layer, 235 armaments were lost, Attacker now has 4655 soldiers left in Melee layer, 7506 total.

[1] is 0.115677966102
From Melee layer, Defender has dealt Attacker 929 casualties to their Melee layer, 929 armaments were lost, Attacker now has 3726 soldiers left in Melee layer, 6577 total.
Ma Dieu's recuperates 15 efficiency
Chao Niu's recuperates 13 efficiency
Mang Yue's recuperates 15 efficiency
Wu Haiyao's recuperates 12 efficiency
You Meng's recuperates 12 efficiency
Zhuang Wu's recuperates 12 efficiency
Fang Han's recuperates 19 efficiency
Pan Shaozu's recuperates 19 efficiency
Huang Liao's recuperates 21 efficiency
Anguo Shuangdi's recuperates 14 efficiency
Jia Huangfu's recuperates 14 efficiency
Mei Shun's recuperates 12 efficiency
Re Ben's recuperates 18 efficiency
Xian Dun's recuperates 12 efficiency
Shen Feng's recuperates 18 efficiency
Fei Lai's recuperates 17 efficiency
Ce Canhuang's recuperates 16 efficiency
Jie Juetie's recuperates 17 efficiency
Kuan Dun's recuperates 22 efficiency
Cao Ren's recuperates 18 efficiency
Lu Qian's recuperates 18 efficiency
Xu Huang's recuperates 18 efficiency
Xu Shang's recuperates 17 efficiency
Yin Shu's recuperates 14 efficiency
Zhu Gai's recuperates 16 efficiency
Sima Yi's recuperates 23 efficiency
Xiahou Dun's recuperates 21 efficiency
Zhang He's recuperates 21 efficiency
Mao MaRen's recuperates 19 efficiency
Ban Dong's recuperates 17 efficiency
Cang Ben's recuperates 11 efficiency
Chao Jian's recuperates 15 efficiency
Gao Lue's recuperates 14 efficiency
Jiu Xue's recuperates 16 efficiency
Luo Ou's recuperates 17 efficiency
Yin Gong's recuperates 16 efficiency

Ma Dieu's efficiency is at 70
Chao Niu's efficiency is at 100
Mang Yue's efficiency is at 100
Wu Haiyao's efficiency is at 100
You Meng's efficiency is at 100
Zhuang Wu's efficiency is at 100
Fang Han's efficiency is at 100
Pan Shaozu's efficiency is at 89
Huang Liao's efficiency is at 91
Anguo Shuangdi's efficiency is at 100
Jia Huangfu's efficiency is at 100
Mei Shun's efficiency is at 100
Re Ben's efficiency is at 88
Xian Dun's efficiency is at 100
Shen Feng's efficiency is at 88
Fei Lai's efficiency is at 87
Ce Canhuang's efficiency is at 100
Jie Juetie's efficiency is at 100
Kuan Dun's efficiency is at 100
Cao Ren's efficiency is at 73
Lu Qian's efficiency is at 100
Xu Huang's efficiency is at 73
Xu Shang's efficiency is at 100
Yin Shu's efficiency is at 100
Zhu Gai's efficiency is at 100
Sima Yi's efficiency is at 93
Xiahou Dun's efficiency is at 91
Zhang He's efficiency is at 91
Mao MaRen's efficiency is at 89
Ban Dong's efficiency is at 100
Cang Ben's efficiency is at 96
Chao Jian's efficiency is at 100
Gao Lue's efficiency is at 100
Jiu Xue's efficiency is at 100
Luo Ou's efficiency is at 100
Yin Gong's efficiency is at 100

Battle results Part 2

Army Melee Soldiers Support Soldiers Supplies Morale Melee Attack Melee Armaments Support Attack Support Armaments Melee Defense Support Defense Speed
Attackers 3726 2851 75 54 167 3726 153 1618 138 113 111
Defenders 3436 1500 65 56 165 3436 186 1500 135 126 98

Ma Dieu's efficiency is at 70
Chao Niu's efficiency is at 100
Mang Yue's efficiency is at 100
Wu Haiyao's efficiency is at 100
You Meng's efficiency is at 100
Zhuang Wu's efficiency is at 100
Fang Han's efficiency is at 100
Pan Shaozu's efficiency is at 89
Huang Liao's efficiency is at 91
Anguo Shuangdi's efficiency is at 100
Jia Huangfu's efficiency is at 100
Mei Shun's efficiency is at 100
Re Ben's efficiency is at 88
Xian Dun's efficiency is at 100
Shen Feng's efficiency is at 88
Fei Lai's efficiency is at 87
Ce Canhuang's efficiency is at 100
Jie Juetie's efficiency is at 100
Kuan Dun's efficiency is at 100
Cao Ren's efficiency is at 73
Lu Qian's efficiency is at 100
Xu Huang's efficiency is at 73
Xu Shang's efficiency is at 100
Yin Shu's efficiency is at 100
Zhu Gai's efficiency is at 100
Sima Yi's efficiency is at 93
Xiahou Dun's efficiency is at 91
Zhang He's efficiency is at 91
Mao MaRen's efficiency is at 89
Ban Dong's efficiency is at 100
Cang Ben's efficiency is at 96
Chao Jian's efficiency is at 100
Gao Lue's efficiency is at 100
Jiu Xue's efficiency is at 100
Luo Ou's efficiency is at 100
Yin Gong's efficiency is at 100

Huang Liao succeeds to use Deride 1 (had 43% chance to succeed, got 29) to lower opp support morale by 9
Mao MaRen succeeds to use Discipline 2 (had 82% chance to succeed, got 6) to raise own soldiers morale by 18
Fang Han succeeds to use Escort 1 (had 55% chance to succeed, got 35) to raise own army supplies by 5
Re Ben succeeds to use Raid 1 (had 79% chance to succeed, got 68) to lower opp support supplies by 4
Fei Lai succeeds to use Escort 2 (had 54% chance to succeed, got 48) to raise own army supplies by 9
Jie Juetie fails to use Raid 2 (had 87% chance to succeed, got 91)
Shen Feng fails to use Guard 2 (had 40% chance to succeed, got 45)
Xiahou Dun succeeds to use Raid 2 (had 90% chance to succeed, got 63) to lower opp support supplies by 9
Jiu Xue succeeds to use Raid 1 (had 90% chance to succeed, got 62) to lower opp support supplies by 5
Sima Yi succeeds to use Poison 2 (had 90% chance to succeed, got 56) to lower opp support supplies by 9
Ban Dong fails to use Guard 1 (had 10% chance to succeed, got 84)
Cang Ben succeeds to use Poison 1 (had 12% chance to succeed, got 10) to lower opp support supplies by 5
Zhang He succeeds to use Rupture 2 (had 90% chance to succeed, got 14) to lower opp melee defense by 18 (108)
Luo Ou succeeds to use Barricade 1 (had 90% chance to succeed, got 44) to raise own support defense by 10 (130)
Kuan Dun fails to use Faze 1 (had 89% chance to succeed, got 99)
Pan Shaozu succeeds to use Succor 1 (had 69% chance to succeed, got 22) to raise own officer (Shen Feng) effectivness by 9
Ce Canhuang fails to use Aid 2 (had 17% chance to succeed, got 74)
Cao Ren fails to use Aid 2 (had 42% chance to succeed, got 73)
Xu Huang fails to use Aid 1 (had 33% chance to succeed, got 78)

Updated stats after tactics
Army Melee Soldiers Support Soldiers Supplies Morale Melee Attack Melee Armaments Support Attack Support Armaments Melee Defense Support Defense Speed
Attackers 3726 2851 61 54 155 3726 142 1618 108 101 111
Defenders 3436 1500 61 65 162 3436 182 1500 130 130 98



Att Mel vs Def Mel 0.0834615384615
Att Sup vs Def Mel 0.104861538462
Att Sup vs Def Sup 0.104861538462
Def Mel vs Att Mel 0.105
Def Sup vs Att Mel 0.161777777778
Def Sup vs Att Sup 0.17299009901
Att Mel Att 155
Def Mel Def 130
Def Mel Att 162
Att Mel Def 108
Att Sup Att 142
Def Sup Def 130
Def Sup Att 182
Att Sup Def 101
Attacker's speed is higher and will strike first!

[1] is 0.104861538462
From Support layer, Attacker has dealt Defender 294 casualties to their Melee layer, 294 armaments were lost, Defender now has 3142 soldiers left in Melee layer, 4642 total.

[1] is 0.0834615384615
From Melee layer, Attacker has dealt Defender 549 casualties to their Melee layer, 549 armaments were lost, Defender now has 2593 soldiers left in Melee layer, 4093 total.

[1] is 0.161777777778
From Support layer, Defender has dealt Attacker 244 casualties to their Melee layer, 244 armaments were lost, Attacker now has 3482 soldiers left in Melee layer, 6333 total.

[1] is 0.105
From Melee layer, Defender has dealt Attacker 636 casualties to their Melee layer, 636 armaments were lost, Attacker now has 2846 soldiers left in Melee layer, 5697 total.
Ma Dieu's recuperates 15 efficiency
Chao Niu's recuperates 13 efficiency
Mang Yue's recuperates 15 efficiency
Wu Haiyao's recuperates 12 efficiency
You Meng's recuperates 12 efficiency
Zhuang Wu's recuperates 12 efficiency
Fang Han's recuperates 19 efficiency
Pan Shaozu's recuperates 19 efficiency
Huang Liao's recuperates 21 efficiency
Anguo Shuangdi's recuperates 14 efficiency
Jia Huangfu's recuperates 14 efficiency
Mei Shun's recuperates 12 efficiency
Re Ben's recuperates 18 efficiency
Xian Dun's recuperates 12 efficiency
Shen Feng's recuperates 18 efficiency
Fei Lai's recuperates 17 efficiency
Ce Canhuang's recuperates 16 efficiency
Jie Juetie's recuperates 17 efficiency
Kuan Dun's recuperates 22 efficiency
Cao Ren's recuperates 19 efficiency
Lu Qian's recuperates 19 efficiency
Xu Huang's recuperates 19 efficiency
Xu Shang's recuperates 18 efficiency
Yin Shu's recuperates 15 efficiency
Zhu Gai's recuperates 17 efficiency
Sima Yi's recuperates 24 efficiency
Xiahou Dun's recuperates 22 efficiency
Zhang He's recuperates 22 efficiency
Mao MaRen's recuperates 20 efficiency
Ban Dong's recuperates 18 efficiency
Cang Ben's recuperates 12 efficiency
Chao Jian's recuperates 16 efficiency
Gao Lue's recuperates 15 efficiency
Jiu Xue's recuperates 17 efficiency
Luo Ou's recuperates 18 efficiency
Yin Gong's recuperates 17 efficiency

Ma Dieu's efficiency is at 85
Chao Niu's efficiency is at 100
Mang Yue's efficiency is at 100
Wu Haiyao's efficiency is at 100
You Meng's efficiency is at 100
Zhuang Wu's efficiency is at 100
Fang Han's efficiency is at 100
Pan Shaozu's efficiency is at 93
Huang Liao's efficiency is at 97
Anguo Shuangdi's efficiency is at 100
Jia Huangfu's efficiency is at 100
Mei Shun's efficiency is at 100
Re Ben's efficiency is at 91
Xian Dun's efficiency is at 100
Shen Feng's efficiency is at 85
Fei Lai's efficiency is at 74
Ce Canhuang's efficiency is at 86
Jie Juetie's efficiency is at 87
Kuan Dun's efficiency is at 100
Cao Ren's efficiency is at 62
Lu Qian's efficiency is at 100
Xu Huang's efficiency is at 77
Xu Shang's efficiency is at 100
Yin Shu's efficiency is at 100
Zhu Gai's efficiency is at 100
Sima Yi's efficiency is at 87
Xiahou Dun's efficiency is at 83
Zhang He's efficiency is at 83
Mao MaRen's efficiency is at 79
Ban Dong's efficiency is at 100
Cang Ben's efficiency is at 93
Chao Jian's efficiency is at 100
Gao Lue's efficiency is at 100
Jiu Xue's efficiency is at 100
Luo Ou's efficiency is at 100
Yin Gong's efficiency is at 100

Battle results Part 3

Army Melee Soldiers Support Soldiers Supplies Morale Melee Attack Melee Armaments Support Attack Support Armaments Melee Defense Support Defense Speed
Attackers 2846 2851 61 54 155 2846 142 1618 126 101 90
Defenders 2593 1500 61 65 162 2593 182 1500 130 120 98

Ma Dieu's efficiency is at 85
Chao Niu's efficiency is at 100
Mang Yue's efficiency is at 100
Wu Haiyao's efficiency is at 100
You Meng's efficiency is at 100
Zhuang Wu's efficiency is at 100
Fang Han's efficiency is at 100
Pan Shaozu's efficiency is at 93
Huang Liao's efficiency is at 97
Anguo Shuangdi's efficiency is at 100
Jia Huangfu's efficiency is at 100
Mei Shun's efficiency is at 100
Re Ben's efficiency is at 91
Xian Dun's efficiency is at 100
Shen Feng's efficiency is at 85
Fei Lai's efficiency is at 74
Ce Canhuang's efficiency is at 86
Jie Juetie's efficiency is at 87
Kuan Dun's efficiency is at 100
Cao Ren's efficiency is at 62
Lu Qian's efficiency is at 100
Xu Huang's efficiency is at 77
Xu Shang's efficiency is at 100
Yin Shu's efficiency is at 100
Zhu Gai's efficiency is at 100
Sima Yi's efficiency is at 87
Xiahou Dun's efficiency is at 83
Zhang He's efficiency is at 83
Mao MaRen's efficiency is at 79
Ban Dong's efficiency is at 100
Cang Ben's efficiency is at 93
Chao Jian's efficiency is at 100
Gao Lue's efficiency is at 100
Jiu Xue's efficiency is at 100
Luo Ou's efficiency is at 100
Yin Gong's efficiency is at 100

Ce Canhuang fails to use Deride 1 (had 65% chance to succeed, got 90)
Mao MaRen succeeds to use Discipline 2 (had 73% chance to succeed, got 31) to raise own soldiers morale by 16
Ma Dieu succeeds to use Raid 3 (had 77% chance to succeed, got 51) to lower opp support supplies by 13
Fang Han fails to use Escort 1 (had 55% chance to succeed, got 74)
Re Ben fails to use Raid 2 (had 82% chance to succeed, got 91)
Fei Lai fails to use Escort 2 (had 46% chance to succeed, got 54)
Jie Juetie succeeds to use Raid 1 (had 76% chance to succeed, got 72) to lower opp support supplies by 4
Shen Feng succeeds to use Guard 2 (had 39% chance to succeed, got 37) to raise own army supplies by 9
Xiahou Dun succeeds to use Raid 2 (had 90% chance to succeed, got 83) to lower opp support supplies by 8
Jiu Xue succeeds to use Raid 1 (had 90% chance to succeed, got 78) to lower opp support supplies by 5
Sima Yi succeeds to use Poison 2 (had 90% chance to succeed, got 71) to lower opp support supplies by 9
Cang Ben fails to use Poison 1 (had 11% chance to succeed, got 50)
Luo Ou succeeds to use Guard 1 (had 57% chance to succeed, got 25) to raise own army supplies by 5
Xu Huang succeeds to use Charge 3 (had 67% chance to succeed, got 62) to raise own melee attack by 23 (175)
Zhang He fails to use Rupture 2 (had 90% chance to succeed, got 95)
Cao Ren fails to use Aid 2 (had 50% chance to succeed, got 88)
Ban Dong fails to use Aid 1 (had 19% chance to succeed, got 23)
Kuan Dun succeeds to use Faze 1 (had 89% chance to succeed, got 51) to lower opp officer (Mao MaRen) effectivness by 10
Pan Shaozu succeeds to use Succor 2 (had 72% chance to succeed, got 72) to raise own officer (Shen Feng) effectivness by 19
Huang Liao succeeds to use Aid 1 (had 33% chance to succeed, got 33) to raise own officer (Fei Lai) effectivness by 10

Updated stats after tactics
Army Melee Soldiers Support Soldiers Supplies Morale Melee Attack Melee Armaments Support Attack Support Armaments Melee Defense Support Defense Speed
Attackers 2846 2851 48 54 145 2846 132 1618 126 101 90
Defenders 2593 1500 49 81 175 2593 170 1500 143 132 98



Att Mel vs Def Mel 0.070979020979
Att Sup vs Def Mel 0.0886153846154
Att Sup vs Def Sup 0.096
Def Mel vs Att Mel 0.0972222222222
Def Sup vs Att Mel 0.129523809524
Def Sup vs Att Sup 0.161584158416
Att Mel Att 145
Def Mel Def 143
Def Mel Att 175
Att Mel Def 126
Att Sup Att 132
Def Sup Def 132
Def Sup Att 170
Att Sup Def 101
Defender's speed is higher and will strike first!

[1] is 0.129523809524
From Support layer, Defender has dealt Attacker 195 casualties to their Melee layer, 195 armaments were lost, Attacker now has 2651 soldiers left in Melee layer, 5502 total.

[1] is 0.0972222222222
From Melee layer, Defender has dealt Attacker 493 casualties to their Melee layer, 493 armaments were lost, Attacker now has 2158 soldiers left in Melee layer, 5009 total.

[1] is 0.0886153846154
From Support layer, Attacker has dealt Defender 248 casualties to their Melee layer, 248 armaments were lost, Defender now has 2345 soldiers left in Melee layer, 3845 total.

[1] is 0.070979020979
From Melee layer, Attacker has dealt Defender 328 casualties to their Melee layer, 328 armaments were lost, Defender now has 2017 soldiers left in Melee layer, 3517 total.
Ma Dieu's recuperates 15 efficiency
Chao Niu's recuperates 13 efficiency
Mang Yue's recuperates 15 efficiency
Wu Haiyao's recuperates 12 efficiency
You Meng's recuperates 12 efficiency
Zhuang Wu's recuperates 12 efficiency
Fang Han's recuperates 19 efficiency
Pan Shaozu's recuperates 19 efficiency
Huang Liao's recuperates 21 efficiency
Anguo Shuangdi's recuperates 14 efficiency
Jia Huangfu's recuperates 14 efficiency
Mei Shun's recuperates 12 efficiency
Re Ben's recuperates 18 efficiency
Xian Dun's recuperates 12 efficiency
Shen Feng's recuperates 18 efficiency
Fei Lai's recuperates 17 efficiency
Ce Canhuang's recuperates 16 efficiency
Jie Juetie's recuperates 17 efficiency
Kuan Dun's recuperates 22 efficiency
Cao Ren's recuperates 22 efficiency
Lu Qian's recuperates 22 efficiency
Xu Huang's recuperates 22 efficiency
Xu Shang's recuperates 21 efficiency
Yin Shu's recuperates 18 efficiency
Zhu Gai's recuperates 20 efficiency
Sima Yi's recuperates 27 efficiency
Xiahou Dun's recuperates 25 efficiency
Zhang He's recuperates 25 efficiency
Mao MaRen's recuperates 23 efficiency
Ban Dong's recuperates 21 efficiency
Cang Ben's recuperates 15 efficiency
Chao Jian's recuperates 19 efficiency
Gao Lue's recuperates 18 efficiency
Jiu Xue's recuperates 20 efficiency
Luo Ou's recuperates 21 efficiency
Yin Gong's recuperates 20 efficiency

Ma Dieu's efficiency is at 55
Chao Niu's efficiency is at 100
Mang Yue's efficiency is at 100
Wu Haiyao's efficiency is at 100
You Meng's efficiency is at 100
Zhuang Wu's efficiency is at 100
Fang Han's efficiency is at 100
Pan Shaozu's efficiency is at 82
Huang Liao's efficiency is at 100
Anguo Shuangdi's efficiency is at 100
Jia Huangfu's efficiency is at 100
Mei Shun's efficiency is at 100
Re Ben's efficiency is at 79
Xian Dun's efficiency is at 100
Shen Feng's efficiency is at 92
Fei Lai's efficiency is at 71
Ce Canhuang's efficiency is at 87
Jie Juetie's efficiency is at 89
Kuan Dun's efficiency is at 100
Cao Ren's efficiency is at 54
Lu Qian's efficiency is at 100
Xu Huang's efficiency is at 54
Xu Shang's efficiency is at 100
Yin Shu's efficiency is at 100
Zhu Gai's efficiency is at 100
Sima Yi's efficiency is at 84
Xiahou Dun's efficiency is at 78
Zhang He's efficiency is at 78
Mao MaRen's efficiency is at 62
Ban Dong's efficiency is at 100
Cang Ben's efficiency is at 93
Chao Jian's efficiency is at 100
Gao Lue's efficiency is at 100
Jiu Xue's efficiency is at 100
Luo Ou's efficiency is at 100
Yin Gong's efficiency is at 100

Battle results Part 4

Army Melee Soldiers Support Soldiers Supplies Morale Melee Attack Melee Armaments Support Attack Support Armaments Melee Defense Support Defense Speed
Attackers 2158 2851 48 54 145 2158 132 1618 126 101 72
Defenders 2017 1500 49 81 152 2017 170 1500 143 132 87

Ma Dieu's efficiency is at 55
Chao Niu's efficiency is at 100
Mang Yue's efficiency is at 100
Wu Haiyao's efficiency is at 100
You Meng's efficiency is at 100
Zhuang Wu's efficiency is at 100
Fang Han's efficiency is at 100
Pan Shaozu's efficiency is at 82
Huang Liao's efficiency is at 100
Anguo Shuangdi's efficiency is at 100
Jia Huangfu's efficiency is at 100
Mei Shun's efficiency is at 100
Re Ben's efficiency is at 79
Xian Dun's efficiency is at 100
Shen Feng's efficiency is at 92
Fei Lai's efficiency is at 71
Ce Canhuang's efficiency is at 87
Jie Juetie's efficiency is at 89
Kuan Dun's efficiency is at 100
Cao Ren's efficiency is at 54
Lu Qian's efficiency is at 100
Xu Huang's efficiency is at 54
Xu Shang's efficiency is at 100
Yin Shu's efficiency is at 100
Zhu Gai's efficiency is at 100
Sima Yi's efficiency is at 84
Xiahou Dun's efficiency is at 78
Zhang He's efficiency is at 78
Mao MaRen's efficiency is at 62
Ban Dong's efficiency is at 100
Cang Ben's efficiency is at 93
Chao Jian's efficiency is at 100
Gao Lue's efficiency is at 100
Jiu Xue's efficiency is at 100
Luo Ou's efficiency is at 100
Yin Gong's efficiency is at 100

Mao MaRen fails to use Discipline 2 (had 57% chance to succeed, got 89)
Fang Han succeeds to use Escort 1 (had 55% chance to succeed, got 3) to raise own army supplies by 5
Re Ben succeeds to use Raid 1 (had 71% chance to succeed, got 64) to lower opp support supplies by 4
Fei Lai succeeds to use Escort 2 (had 44% chance to succeed, got 22) to raise own army supplies by 7
Jie Juetie succeeds to use Raid 2 (had 77% chance to succeed, got 7) to lower opp support supplies by 9
Shen Feng succeeds to use Guard 2 (had 42% chance to succeed, got 25) to raise own army supplies by 9
Xiahou Dun succeeds to use Raid 2 (had 89% chance to succeed, got 75) to lower opp support supplies by 8
Jiu Xue fails to use Raid 1 (had 90% chance to succeed, got 96)
Sima Yi succeeds to use Poison 2 (had 90% chance to succeed, got 56) to lower opp support supplies by 8
Ban Dong fails to use Guard 1 (had 10% chance to succeed, got 25)
Cang Ben fails to use Poison 1 (had 11% chance to succeed, got 69)
Zhang He succeeds to use Rupture 2 (had 84% chance to succeed, got 46) to lower opp melee defense by 16 (110)
Luo Ou succeeds to use Barricade 1 (had 90% chance to succeed, got 79) to raise own support defense by 10 (142)
Cao Ren fails to use Aid 2 (had 31% chance to succeed, got 41)
Xu Huang fails to use Aid 1 (had 24% chance to succeed, got 82)
Kuan Dun succeeds to use Faze 1 (had 89% chance to succeed, got 61) to lower opp officer (Mao MaRen) effectivness by 10
Pan Shaozu succeeds to use Succor 1 (had 63% chance to succeed, got 18) to raise own officer (Shen Feng) effectivness by 8
Huang Liao fails to use Aid 1 (had 34% chance to succeed, got 53)
Ce Canhuang succeeds to use Aid 2 (had 15% chance to succeed, got 11) to raise own officer (Fei Lai) effectivness by 17

Updated stats after tactics
Army Melee Soldiers Support Soldiers Supplies Morale Melee Attack Melee Armaments Support Attack Support Armaments Melee Defense Support Defense Speed
Attackers 2158 2851 53 54 149 2158 136 1618 110 101 72
Defenders 2017 1500 36 81 141 2017 158 1500 143 142 87



Att Mel vs Def Mel 0.0729370629371
Att Sup vs Def Mel 0.0913006993007
Att Sup vs Def Sup 0.0919436619718
Def Mel vs Att Mel 0.0897272727273
Def Sup vs Att Mel 0.137890909091
Def Sup vs Att Sup 0.150178217822
Att Mel Att 149
Def Mel Def 143
Def Mel Att 141
Att Mel Def 110
Att Sup Att 136
Def Sup Def 142
Def Sup Att 158
Att Sup Def 101
Defender's speed is higher and will strike first!

[1] is 0.137890909091
From Support layer, Defender has dealt Attacker 205 casualties to their Melee layer, 205 armaments were lost, Attacker now has 1953 soldiers left in Melee layer, 4804 total.

[1] is 0.0897272727273
From Melee layer, Defender has dealt Attacker 344 casualties to their Melee layer, 344 armaments were lost, Attacker now has 1609 soldiers left in Melee layer, 4460 total.

[1] is 0.0913006993007
From Support layer, Attacker has dealt Defender 250 casualties to their Melee layer, 250 armaments were lost, Defender now has 1767 soldiers left in Melee layer, 3267 total.

[1] is 0.0729370629371
From Melee layer, Attacker has dealt Defender 241 casualties to their Melee layer, 241 armaments were lost, Defender now has 1526 soldiers left in Melee layer, 3026 total.
Ma Dieu's recuperates 15 efficiency
Chao Niu's recuperates 13 efficiency
Mang Yue's recuperates 15 efficiency
Wu Haiyao's recuperates 12 efficiency
You Meng's recuperates 12 efficiency
Zhuang Wu's recuperates 12 efficiency
Fang Han's recuperates 19 efficiency
Pan Shaozu's recuperates 19 efficiency
Huang Liao's recuperates 21 efficiency
Anguo Shuangdi's recuperates 14 efficiency
Jia Huangfu's recuperates 14 efficiency
Mei Shun's recuperates 12 efficiency
Re Ben's recuperates 18 efficiency
Xian Dun's recuperates 12 efficiency
Shen Feng's recuperates 18 efficiency
Fei Lai's recuperates 17 efficiency
Ce Canhuang's recuperates 16 efficiency
Jie Juetie's recuperates 17 efficiency
Kuan Dun's recuperates 22 efficiency
Cao Ren's recuperates 22 efficiency
Lu Qian's recuperates 22 efficiency
Xu Huang's recuperates 22 efficiency
Xu Shang's recuperates 21 efficiency
Yin Shu's recuperates 18 efficiency
Zhu Gai's recuperates 20 efficiency
Sima Yi's recuperates 27 efficiency
Xiahou Dun's recuperates 25 efficiency
Zhang He's recuperates 25 efficiency
Mao MaRen's recuperates 23 efficiency
Ban Dong's recuperates 21 efficiency
Cang Ben's recuperates 15 efficiency
Chao Jian's recuperates 19 efficiency
Gao Lue's recuperates 18 efficiency
Jiu Xue's recuperates 20 efficiency
Luo Ou's recuperates 21 efficiency
Yin Gong's recuperates 20 efficiency

Ma Dieu's efficiency is at 70
Chao Niu's efficiency is at 100
Mang Yue's efficiency is at 100
Wu Haiyao's efficiency is at 100
You Meng's efficiency is at 100
Zhuang Wu's efficiency is at 100
Fang Han's efficiency is at 100
Pan Shaozu's efficiency is at 86
Huang Liao's efficiency is at 100
Anguo Shuangdi's efficiency is at 100
Jia Huangfu's efficiency is at 100
Mei Shun's efficiency is at 100
Re Ben's efficiency is at 82
Xian Dun's efficiency is at 100
Shen Feng's efficiency is at 88
Fei Lai's efficiency is at 75
Ce Canhuang's efficiency is at 73
Jie Juetie's efficiency is at 76
Kuan Dun's efficiency is at 100
Cao Ren's efficiency is at 46
Lu Qian's efficiency is at 100
Xu Huang's efficiency is at 61
Xu Shang's efficiency is at 100
Yin Shu's efficiency is at 100
Zhu Gai's efficiency is at 100
Sima Yi's efficiency is at 81
Xiahou Dun's efficiency is at 73
Zhang He's efficiency is at 73
Mao MaRen's efficiency is at 45
Ban Dong's efficiency is at 100
Cang Ben's efficiency is at 93
Chao Jian's efficiency is at 100
Gao Lue's efficiency is at 100
Jiu Xue's efficiency is at 100
Luo Ou's efficiency is at 100
Yin Gong's efficiency is at 100

Battle results Part 5

Army Melee Soldiers Support Soldiers Supplies Morale Melee Attack Melee Armaments Support Attack Support Armaments Melee Defense Support Defense Speed
Attackers 1609 2851 53 54 149 1609 136 1618 126 101 79
Defenders 1526 1500 36 81 141 1526 158 1500 143 132 64

Ma Dieu's efficiency is at 70
Chao Niu's efficiency is at 100
Mang Yue's efficiency is at 100
Wu Haiyao's efficiency is at 100
You Meng's efficiency is at 100
Zhuang Wu's efficiency is at 100
Fang Han's efficiency is at 100
Pan Shaozu's efficiency is at 86
Huang Liao's efficiency is at 100
Anguo Shuangdi's efficiency is at 100
Jia Huangfu's efficiency is at 100
Mei Shun's efficiency is at 100
Re Ben's efficiency is at 82
Xian Dun's efficiency is at 100
Shen Feng's efficiency is at 88
Fei Lai's efficiency is at 75
Ce Canhuang's efficiency is at 73
Jie Juetie's efficiency is at 76
Kuan Dun's efficiency is at 100
Cao Ren's efficiency is at 46
Lu Qian's efficiency is at 100
Xu Huang's efficiency is at 61
Xu Shang's efficiency is at 100
Yin Shu's efficiency is at 100
Zhu Gai's efficiency is at 100
Sima Yi's efficiency is at 81
Xiahou Dun's efficiency is at 73
Zhang He's efficiency is at 73
Mao MaRen's efficiency is at 45
Ban Dong's efficiency is at 100
Cang Ben's efficiency is at 93
Chao Jian's efficiency is at 100
Gao Lue's efficiency is at 100
Jiu Xue's efficiency is at 100
Luo Ou's efficiency is at 100
Yin Gong's efficiency is at 100

Ce Canhuang succeeds to use Deride 1 (had 55% chance to succeed, got 37) to lower opp support morale by 7
Mao MaRen fails to use Discipline 2 (had 41% chance to succeed, got 57)
Ma Dieu succeeds to use Raid 3 (had 64% chance to succeed, got 1) to lower opp support supplies by 11
Fang Han fails to use Escort 1 (had 55% chance to succeed, got 70)
Re Ben succeeds to use Raid 2 (had 74% chance to succeed, got 21) to lower opp support supplies by 8
Fei Lai succeeds to use Escort 2 (had 47% chance to succeed, got 16) to raise own army supplies by 8
Jie Juetie fails to use Raid 1 (had 66% chance to succeed, got 100)
Shen Feng succeeds to use Guard 2 (had 40% chance to succeed, got 7) to raise own army supplies by 9
Xiahou Dun succeeds to use Raid 2 (had 83% chance to succeed, got 4) to lower opp support supplies by 7
Jiu Xue succeeds to use Raid 1 (had 90% chance to succeed, got 3) to lower opp support supplies by 5
Sima Yi succeeds to use Poison 2 (had 90% chance to succeed, got 71) to lower opp support supplies by 8
Cang Ben fails to use Poison 1 (had 11% chance to succeed, got 26)
Luo Ou succeeds to use Guard 1 (had 57% chance to succeed, got 9) to raise own army supplies by 5
Xu Huang fails to use Charge 3 (had 53% chance to succeed, got 95)
Zhang He fails to use Rupture 2 (had 79% chance to succeed, got 100)
Kuan Dun succeeds to use Faze 1 (had 89% chance to succeed, got 5) to lower opp officer (Mao MaRen) effectivness by 10
Pan Shaozu succeeds to use Succor 2 (had 66% chance to succeed, got 50) to raise own officer (Shen Feng) effectivness by 17
Huang Liao succeeds to use Aid 1 (had 34% chance to succeed, got 25) to raise own officer (Fei Lai) effectivness by 10
Cao Ren fails to use Aid 2 (had 25% chance to succeed, got 74)
Ban Dong fails to use Aid 1 (had 10% chance to succeed, got 96)

Updated stats after tactics
Army Melee Soldiers Support Soldiers Supplies Morale Melee Attack Melee Armaments Support Attack Support Armaments Melee Defense Support Defense Speed
Attackers 1609 2851 50 54 147 1609 133 1618 126 101 79
Defenders 1526 1500 22 74 129 1526 144 1500 137 127 64



Att Mel vs Def Mel 0.0751094890511
Att Sup vs Def Mel 0.093197080292
Att Sup vs Def Sup 0.100535433071
Def Mel vs Att Mel 0.0716666666667
Def Sup vs Att Mel 0.109714285714
Def Sup vs Att Sup 0.136871287129
Att Mel Att 147
Def Mel Def 137
Def Mel Att 129
Att Mel Def 126
Att Sup Att 133
Def Sup Def 127
Def Sup Att 144
Att Sup Def 101
Attacker's speed is higher and will strike first!

[1] is 0.093197080292
From Support layer, Attacker has dealt Defender 255 casualties to their Melee layer, 255 armaments were lost, Defender now has 1271 soldiers left in Melee layer, 2771 total.

[1] is 0.0751094890511
From Melee layer, Attacker has dealt Defender 209 casualties to their Melee layer, 209 armaments were lost, Defender now has 1062 soldiers left in Melee layer, 2562 total.

[1] is 0.109714285714
From Support layer, Defender has dealt Attacker 168 casualties to their Melee layer, 168 armaments were lost, Attacker now has 1441 soldiers left in Melee layer, 4292 total.

[1] is 0.0716666666667
From Melee layer, Defender has dealt Attacker 180 casualties to their Melee layer, 180 armaments were lost, Attacker now has 1261 soldiers left in Melee layer, 4112 total.
Ma Dieu's recuperates 15 efficiency
Chao Niu's recuperates 13 efficiency
Mang Yue's recuperates 15 efficiency
Wu Haiyao's recuperates 12 efficiency
You Meng's recuperates 12 efficiency
Zhuang Wu's recuperates 12 efficiency
Fang Han's recuperates 19 efficiency
Pan Shaozu's recuperates 19 efficiency
Huang Liao's recuperates 21 efficiency
Anguo Shuangdi's recuperates 14 efficiency
Jia Huangfu's recuperates 14 efficiency
Mei Shun's recuperates 12 efficiency
Re Ben's recuperates 18 efficiency
Xian Dun's recuperates 12 efficiency
Shen Feng's recuperates 18 efficiency
Fei Lai's recuperates 17 efficiency
Ce Canhuang's recuperates 16 efficiency
Jie Juetie's recuperates 17 efficiency
Kuan Dun's recuperates 22 efficiency
Cao Ren's recuperates 21 efficiency
Lu Qian's recuperates 21 efficiency
Xu Huang's recuperates 21 efficiency
Xu Shang's recuperates 20 efficiency
Yin Shu's recuperates 17 efficiency
Zhu Gai's recuperates 19 efficiency
Sima Yi's recuperates 26 efficiency
Xiahou Dun's recuperates 24 efficiency
Zhang He's recuperates 24 efficiency
Mao MaRen's recuperates 22 efficiency
Ban Dong's recuperates 20 efficiency
Cang Ben's recuperates 14 efficiency
Chao Jian's recuperates 18 efficiency
Gao Lue's recuperates 17 efficiency
Jiu Xue's recuperates 19 efficiency
Luo Ou's recuperates 20 efficiency
Yin Gong's recuperates 19 efficiency

Ma Dieu's efficiency is at 40
Chao Niu's efficiency is at 100
Mang Yue's efficiency is at 100
Wu Haiyao's efficiency is at 100
You Meng's efficiency is at 100
Zhuang Wu's efficiency is at 100
Fang Han's efficiency is at 100
Pan Shaozu's efficiency is at 75
Huang Liao's efficiency is at 100
Anguo Shuangdi's efficiency is at 100
Jia Huangfu's efficiency is at 100
Mei Shun's efficiency is at 100
Re Ben's efficiency is at 70
Xian Dun's efficiency is at 100
Shen Feng's efficiency is at 93
Fei Lai's efficiency is at 72
Ce Canhuang's efficiency is at 74
Jie Juetie's efficiency is at 78
Kuan Dun's efficiency is at 100
Cao Ren's efficiency is at 37
Lu Qian's efficiency is at 100
Xu Huang's efficiency is at 37
Xu Shang's efficiency is at 100
Yin Shu's efficiency is at 100
Zhu Gai's efficiency is at 100
Sima Yi's efficiency is at 77
Xiahou Dun's efficiency is at 67
Zhang He's efficiency is at 67
Mao MaRen's efficiency is at 27
Ban Dong's efficiency is at 100
Cang Ben's efficiency is at 92
Chao Jian's efficiency is at 100
Gao Lue's efficiency is at 100
Jiu Xue's efficiency is at 100
Luo Ou's efficiency is at 100
Yin Gong's efficiency is at 100

Battle results Part 6

Army Melee Soldiers Support Soldiers Supplies Morale Melee Attack Melee Armaments Support Attack Support Armaments Melee Defense Support Defense Speed
Attackers 1261 2851 50 54 147 1261 133 1618 126 101 75
Defenders 1062 1500 22 74 129 1062 144 1500 137 127 38

Ma Dieu's efficiency is at 40
Chao Niu's efficiency is at 100
Mang Yue's efficiency is at 100
Wu Haiyao's efficiency is at 100
You Meng's efficiency is at 100
Zhuang Wu's efficiency is at 100
Fang Han's efficiency is at 100
Pan Shaozu's efficiency is at 75
Huang Liao's efficiency is at 100
Anguo Shuangdi's efficiency is at 100
Jia Huangfu's efficiency is at 100
Mei Shun's efficiency is at 100
Re Ben's efficiency is at 70
Xian Dun's efficiency is at 100
Shen Feng's efficiency is at 93
Fei Lai's efficiency is at 72
Ce Canhuang's efficiency is at 74
Jie Juetie's efficiency is at 78
Kuan Dun's efficiency is at 100
Cao Ren's efficiency is at 37
Lu Qian's efficiency is at 100
Xu Huang's efficiency is at 37
Xu Shang's efficiency is at 100
Yin Shu's efficiency is at 100
Zhu Gai's efficiency is at 100
Sima Yi's efficiency is at 77
Xiahou Dun's efficiency is at 67
Zhang He's efficiency is at 67
Mao MaRen's efficiency is at 27
Ban Dong's efficiency is at 100
Cang Ben's efficiency is at 92
Chao Jian's efficiency is at 100
Gao Lue's efficiency is at 100
Jiu Xue's efficiency is at 100
Luo Ou's efficiency is at 100
Yin Gong's efficiency is at 100

Mao MaRen fails to use Discipline 2 (had 25% chance to succeed, got 31)
Xiahou Dun succeeds to use Raid 2 (had 76% chance to succeed, got 30) to lower opp support supplies by 7
Jiu Xue succeeds to use Raid 1 (had 90% chance to succeed, got 75) to lower opp support supplies by 5
Sima Yi succeeds to use Poison 2 (had 90% chance to succeed, got 73) to lower opp support supplies by 8
Cang Ben fails to use Poison 1 (had 11% chance to succeed, got 45)
Luo Ou fails to use Guard 1 (had 57% chance to succeed, got 80)
Ma Dieu succeeds to use Charge 2 (had 32% chance to succeed, got 3) to raise own melee attack by 8 (138)
Fang Han fails to use Decoy 1 (had 78% chance to succeed, got 81)
Re Ben succeeds to use Charge 1 (had 68% chance to succeed, got 36) to raise own melee attack by 7 (145)
Fei Lai succeeds to use Charge 3 (had 66% chance to succeed, got 3) to raise own melee attack by 22 (167)
Pan Shaozu succeeds to use Support 2 (had 59% chance to succeed, got 50) to raise own melee attack by 15 (182)
Shen Feng fails to use Volley 2 (had 33% chance to succeed, got 57)
Cao Ren succeeds to use Charge 1 (had 34% chance to succeed, got 18) to raise own melee attack by 4 (133)
Xu Huang fails to use Charge 3 (had 32% chance to succeed, got 50)
Jie Juetie succeeds to use Rupture 1 (had 66% chance to succeed, got 63) to lower opp melee defense by 8 (129)
Kuan Dun succeeds to use Wall 1 (had 70% chance to succeed, got 22) to raise own melee defense by 10 (136)
Huang Liao succeeds to use Scout 3 (had 66% chance to succeed, got 52) to lower opp melee defense by 30 (99)
Zhang He succeeds to use Rupture 2 (had 72% chance to succeed, got 34) to lower opp melee defense by 13 (123)
Ce Canhuang fails to use Aid 2 (had 13% chance to succeed, got 48)
Ban Dong fails to use Aid 1 (had 10% chance to succeed, got 61)

Updated stats after tactics
Army Melee Soldiers Support Soldiers Supplies Morale Melee Attack Melee Armaments Support Attack Support Armaments Melee Defense Support Defense Speed
Attackers 1261 2851 30 54 182 1261 117 1618 123 101 75
Defenders 1062 1500 22 74 133 1062 144 1500 99 127 38



Att Mel vs Def Mel 0.128686868687
Att Sup vs Def Mel 0.113454545455
Att Sup vs Def Sup 0.0884409448819
Def Mel vs Att Mel 0.0756910569106
Def Sup vs Att Mel 0.112390243902
Def Sup vs Att Sup 0.136871287129
Att Mel Att 182
Def Mel Def 99
Def Mel Att 133
Att Mel Def 123
Att Sup Att 117
Def Sup Def 127
Def Sup Att 144
Att Sup Def 101
Attacker's speed is higher and will strike first!

[1] is 0.113454545455
From Support layer, Attacker has dealt Defender 316 casualties to their Melee layer, 316 armaments were lost, Defender now has 746 soldiers left in Melee layer, 2246 total.

[1] is 0.128686868687
From Melee layer, Attacker has dealt Defender 256 casualties to their Melee layer, 256 armaments were lost, Defender now has 490 soldiers left in Melee layer, 1990 total.

[1] is 0.112390243902
From Support layer, Defender has dealt Attacker 170 casualties to their Melee layer, 170 armaments were lost, Attacker now has 1091 soldiers left in Melee layer, 3942 total.

[1] is 0.0756910569106
From Melee layer, Defender has dealt Attacker 122 casualties to their Melee layer, 122 armaments were lost, Attacker now has 969 soldiers left in Melee layer, 3820 total.
Ma Dieu's recuperates 15 efficiency
Chao Niu's recuperates 13 efficiency
Mang Yue's recuperates 15 efficiency
Wu Haiyao's recuperates 12 efficiency
You Meng's recuperates 12 efficiency
Zhuang Wu's recuperates 12 efficiency
Fang Han's recuperates 19 efficiency
Pan Shaozu's recuperates 19 efficiency
Huang Liao's recuperates 21 efficiency
Anguo Shuangdi's recuperates 14 efficiency
Jia Huangfu's recuperates 14 efficiency
Mei Shun's recuperates 12 efficiency
Re Ben's recuperates 18 efficiency
Xian Dun's recuperates 12 efficiency
Shen Feng's recuperates 18 efficiency
Fei Lai's recuperates 17 efficiency
Ce Canhuang's recuperates 16 efficiency
Jie Juetie's recuperates 17 efficiency
Kuan Dun's recuperates 22 efficiency
Cao Ren's recuperates 21 efficiency
Lu Qian's recuperates 21 efficiency
Xu Huang's recuperates 21 efficiency
Xu Shang's recuperates 20 efficiency
Yin Shu's recuperates 17 efficiency
Zhu Gai's recuperates 19 efficiency
Sima Yi's recuperates 26 efficiency
Xiahou Dun's recuperates 24 efficiency
Zhang He's recuperates 24 efficiency
Mao MaRen's recuperates 22 efficiency
Ban Dong's recuperates 20 efficiency
Cang Ben's recuperates 14 efficiency
Chao Jian's recuperates 18 efficiency
Gao Lue's recuperates 17 efficiency
Jiu Xue's recuperates 19 efficiency
Luo Ou's recuperates 20 efficiency
Yin Gong's recuperates 19 efficiency

Ma Dieu's efficiency is at 25
Chao Niu's efficiency is at 100
Mang Yue's efficiency is at 100
Wu Haiyao's efficiency is at 100
You Meng's efficiency is at 100
Zhuang Wu's efficiency is at 100
Fang Han's efficiency is at 100
Pan Shaozu's efficiency is at 64
Huang Liao's efficiency is at 76
Anguo Shuangdi's efficiency is at 100
Jia Huangfu's efficiency is at 100
Mei Shun's efficiency is at 100
Re Ben's efficiency is at 73
Xian Dun's efficiency is at 100
Shen Feng's efficiency is at 81
Fei Lai's efficiency is at 44
Ce Canhuang's efficiency is at 60
Jie Juetie's efficiency is at 80
Kuan Dun's efficiency is at 100
Cao Ren's efficiency is at 43
Lu Qian's efficiency is at 100
Xu Huang's efficiency is at 21
Xu Shang's efficiency is at 100
Yin Shu's efficiency is at 100
Zhu Gai's efficiency is at 100
Sima Yi's efficiency is at 73
Xiahou Dun's efficiency is at 61
Zhang He's efficiency is at 61
Mao MaRen's efficiency is at 22
Ban Dong's efficiency is at 100
Cang Ben's efficiency is at 91
Chao Jian's efficiency is at 100
Gao Lue's efficiency is at 100
Jiu Xue's efficiency is at 100
Luo Ou's efficiency is at 100
Yin Gong's efficiency is at 100

User avatar
Mardagg
GameBreaker
Posts: 1536
Joined: Mon Jul 14, 2008 12:10 pm
Location: Qui sème le vent récolte la tempête

Re: Tactic balance

Postby Mardagg » Fri May 12, 2017 11:45 am

supply hit should not affect attack: even 5% hit to attack in the first round will give 51 less attack for the 6 rounds (170att * 5% = 8,5 *6 = 51) that is like charge 3 charge 2 for 75 effectiveness cost compare to the 15 effectiveness cost to do raid 1 (and raid 1 also reduce speed by 5%)

supply hit can be reduce to 5-10-15 and at 0 you loose the battle (but no impact on attack), morale can affect more the effectiveness making it lot harder to spawm a level 2 tactics each rounds this way we can focus on other tactics than raid and escort and do lot more dmg in a battle EDIT AUTO WIN OR HAVE VERY HIGH DESERTION PROBLEM

Also we can change the stats taking in account in the tactics to make it harder to do it:

Raid is com+might-ing (all commander have high com and might (because att/def is com, might, judg) and few have high ing) so it can become might +ing - com

Poison is not as bad because it is targetting com, (judg +ing-com), but all support commander have high com, ing, judg so we can make it might + judg - com

MORALE

(Charm - 40) / 4 so if you have 20 charm you loose 5 effectiveness, but if you have 60 you gain 5

10 charm you loose 8 effectiveness
20 charm you loose 5 effectiveness
30 charm you loose 3 effectiveness
40 charm you gain 0 effectiveness
50 charm you gain 3 effectiveness
60 charm you gain 5 effectiveness
70 charm you gain 8 effectiveness
80 charm you gain 10 effectiveness
90 charm you gain 13 effectiveness
100 charm you gain 15 effectiveness

(Morale - 50) / 3 if you have:

Morale
0 you loose 17 effectiveness
10 you loose 13 effectiveness
20 you loose 10 effectiveness
30 you loose 7 effectiveness
40 you loose 3 effectiveness
50 you loose 0 effectiveness
60 you gain 3 effectiveness
70 you gain 7 effectiveness
80 you gain 10 effectiveness
90 you gain 13 effectiveness
100 you gain 17 effectiveness

we can put a tactics call rest to regain effectiveness if we what

ALSO: It would be fun to have a +3/-3 moral modifier (or +5/-5) each round for the one who win the round and the one who loose.

User avatar
Phailak
Administrator
Administrator
Posts: 6198
Joined: Fri Aug 18, 2006 9:55 am
Location: PHP world of Warlords :)
Contact:

Re: Tactic balance

Postby Phailak » Fri May 12, 2017 12:29 pm

This is all good stuff for next version, but to implement here is too complicated, we have to try and stay within same system and tweak


Return to “Other Game Concepts”

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 2 guests